Re: Articles

9946
Guardians’ Steven Kwan savors his first series in San Francisco: ‘It gave me chills’
Image
Cleveland Guardians' Steven Kwan watches his RBI single against the San Francisco Giants during the seventh inning of a baseball game, Monday, Sept. 11, 2023, in San Francisco. (AP Photo/Godofredo A. Vásquez)
By Andrew Baggarly
Sep 13, 2023

50
Save Article

SAN FRANCISCO — So much of the newness and novelty has worn off for Steven Kwan.

His irrepressible debut for the Cleveland Guardians last season? Those 19 times he reached base in his first six games? The much-ballyhooed statistical observation that he saw 116 pitches before he swung and missed, which was the most by any player to start his career in at least two decades? All of that is just part of his Wikipedia page now. He has settled into his second season as the Guardians’ leadoff hitter and starting left fielder — a position that he’s played so well that he nearly laps the field in Defensive Runs Saved. Last year, he was the second toughest hitter in the American League to strike out. This year, with Luis Arraez having departed to the National League, he ranks first.

Kwan’s skills continue to translate. He’s proven he belongs. He is just another workaday big leaguer now, keeping his head down and sticking to his routine and treating road ballparks with all the businesslike tedium of a sales convention.

Until Monday night. That’s when he played his first major-league game in San Francisco. And everything was new again.

“Oh my gosh, just hearing (PA announcer Renel Brooks-Moon) say my name and see my face up on the scoreboard, that was one of those moments that really gave me chills and just put everything in perspective,” Kwan said. “I think it’s easy to get desensitized over the year, being at the ballpark and traveling to big cities, but this was one of those where, like, I got the little tingles and the butterflies again, which felt really cool.”

Kwan, who graduated from Washington High in Fremont, Calif., is hardly having a rare experience. The Bay Area produces big leaguers by the dozen. He’s far from the first visiting player to coast into second base, exchange pleasantries with Brandon Crawford, and drop an “I watched you growing up” on him. But Kwan’s roots are as San Francisco as it gets. His father, Ray, is a second-generation American who was raised in San Francisco near the intersection of Mason and Jackson streets, one block from the cable car barn and museum.

“The house would shake every 20 minutes,” Ray Kwan said.

Ray Kwan grew up going to Giants games at Candlestick Park, often scoring tickets from a cousin as a reward for good grades. His wife, Jane, grew up a Giants fan in Sunnyvale, Calif. Some of their best family memories involve taking their sons, Steven and Ryan, and daughter Christine, to games at the Giants’ waterfront ballpark. Garlic fries were an essential part of the experience. Steven would seek out clam chowder in a bread bowl from the stand behind the center field scoreboard. There was the time when former Giant Rich Aurilia was sitting in an adjacent row and Steven took a picture with him.

Steven never stayed in his seat for any length of time. He was obsessed with the fan zone at the base of the Coke bottle slide above the left-field bleachers. He and Ryan would pelt Wiffle balls in the kids’ play area. Then they’d wait their turn to throw their hardest for the radar gun.

Steven Kwan is a 5-foot-9, 170-pound big leaguer. So you can imagine how big he was as an 8-year-old.

“I was just happy to hit the catcher’s mitt, but all the staff was super supportive,” he said. “They made me feel like I was throwing the heck out of it.”

They didn’t have to pretend. Steven usually put himself on the leaderboard for his age group.

“That was the biggest thrill — checking back every inning to see if anyone beat you,” he said. “If you still had the fastest throw in the seventh inning, you got a baseball card. That was, like, a big achievement.”

Now 26 years old, Kwan’s eyes still light up when he thinks back to winning those cards. He got Shea Hillenbrand one time, Ryan Garko another. It didn’t matter that those players weren’t Giants’ franchise stars. In a sense, those cards were his first bits of validation in what would become a high-achieving career that took him to Oregon State and into pro ball.

Kwan delivered a predictable result in the seventh inning of the Guardians’ eventual 5-4, 10-inning loss Monday night. Giants right-hander John Brebbia had an 0-2 count on him and tried to overpower him with a 95 mph fastball above the top of the zone. Kwan flicked a hard groundball into center field for an RBI single that tied the game. When he jogged to left field in the bottom of the inning, the fans in the bleachers were all over him.

“They definitely let me hear it, which is funny, because I remember a day game when I had tickets out there and the fans were heckling the left fielder,” Kwan said. “I thought it was the funniest thing ever. And now to be on the other end of that was definitely something to experience.”

Kwan’s cheering section here at Oracle Park is much more modest than last year’s first visit to Oakland, which came just a few weeks into his rookie season while he was still being treated like a national sensation.

“It’s all a little more normal now,” Jane Kwan said. “But we still get nervous when he’s at bat. You’re always nervous as a mother.”

If there’s any disappointment, it’s that fellow Oregon State product and Giants rookie Wade Meckler isn’t here after getting sent down to Triple A earlier this month. Meckler is a contact-hitting grinder who had to overcome similar doubts because of his size. When Kwan first arrived at Oregon State, he so doubted his place that he took a two-month break and spoke to a sports psychologist. He went on to hit .355 while leading the Beavers to a national championship in 2018. The year after Kwan started his pro career, Meckler arrived as a redshirt freshman. And Kwan was held up to him as proof of concept.

When Kwan would come back to Corvallis, Ore., to work with his former teammates and Beavers hitting coach Tyler Graham, Meckler often slotted into the cage after him.

“I was always rooting for him,” Kwan said. “We’re the same kind of player. And he hurt his hamstring a couple times, which was something I had to deal with as well. So I was able to counsel him about that. I could tell right away that the guy grinds. If you tell him something, he’ll drive it into the ground until he gets it.”

Kwan recalled hosting a house party one night with a bunch of current and former Oregon State players when Meckler showed up late.

“I want to say it was 1:30, maybe 2 in the morning, we’re all kind of hanging out, talking about whatever, playing games,” Kwan said. “And Wade comes in and you could tell he had something on his mind from hitting earlier in the day.”

Meckler had a TAP ball cradled between his elbow and ribs — a training aide to help maintain posture and body position during athletic movements.

“And you look over and he’s in the corner with the TAP ball feeling out a (swing) load he worked on earlier in the day, just repping it out,” Kwan said. “A few guys were making fun of him, like, ‘Wade, what are you doing?’ Wade was like, ‘T-Graham told me I gotta get 100 of these to really imprint this feel.’ I couldn’t believe it. I think that was the first time that I said to myself, ‘Wow, this guy is really serious about hitting.’”

Kwan looks forward to the day when he and Meckler can oppose each other in a big-league game. For now, there’s plenty of other moments and jogged memories in this series for Cleveland’s visiting left fielder to appreciate.

Before he leaves town, Kwan hopes to reenact one more experience. He’s made inquiries about sliding down the Coke bottle one more time. He was disappointed to learn that the Giants no longer allow guests over 14 to use the slide. There was a lawsuit or two, and you never know how much an adult has had to drink. But perhaps they’d make an exception. It’s unlike Kwan to try to do anything and strike out.

Besides, he more than meets the height requirement.
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain

Re: Articles

9947
From an article by Jim Bowden ranking rookie impact. Cleveland was 3rd in all of baseball.

3. Cleveland Guardians


Grade: A

Notable rookies: Tanner Bibee, RHP (3.2 WAR); Gavin Williams, RHP (1.4 WAR); Logan Allen, LHP (1.8 WAR); Xzavion Curry, RHP (0.4 WAR); Will Brennan, OF (0.8 WAR)

The Guardians lost their two aces, Shane Bieber and Triston McKenzie, to injuries but managed to stay in the AL Central race longer than expected because of their exciting trio of rookie starting pitchers: Bibee, Williams and Allen. Bibee has not only been the best rookie on the Guardians, but also arguably the best rookie pitcher in the entire AL; he’s 10-4 with a 3.03 ERA in 20 starts. All three rookie starters have ERAs under 4.00 and have been consistent all year. In addition, manager Terry Francona told me that Curry was the reliever who saved them this year and was the most “under the radar, indispensable player” on the roster.
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain

Re: Articles

9949
CLEVELAND, Ohio — Andrés Giménez is quietly having a September to remember for the Guardians, both at the plate and in the field, reversing a trend that saw the 2022 All-Star sink to a .211 batting average during games in July.

The turnaround for Giménez over the last three weeks has put Cleveland’s second baseman in the conversation as one of the American League’s best hitters this month.
Giménez is batting .348 with a .864 OPS, 10 RBI and 10 runs scored in 18 games played during September. He has multiple hits in nine of his 18 games this month, including four of his last six contests. Among American League hitters this month, Giménez ranks first in singles (19), second in total hits (24) and steals (8) and fifth in batting average.

That’s a stark contrast for Giménez, who hit .250 in March/April before trending in the wrong direction through June. An abysmal July saw Giménez post a .299 OPS and .389 slugging percentage. [688 OPS is mediocre, not abysmal]
[The abysmal month was May: 272/299]

September’s numbers resemble more what was expected from the 24-year-old infielder at the start of the season. Giménez’s ability to repeat his output at the plate over an extended stretch has been elusive, but that consistency has been welcome, said manager Terry Francona.

“That’s been hard for him this year,” Francona said. “He hasn’t been able to hold it for as long. But it’s nice to see him take more swings lately like we know he can.”

Power numbers have taken a turn for the better for Giménez, as well. With 26 doubles and 20 steals last season and 26 doubles and 30 steals so far this season, Giménez joins Grady Sizemore (2005-07) and Shoeless Joe Jackson (1911-12) as the only Cleveland hitters with multiple seasons of 25 or more doubles and 20 or more steals by age 24.

He also became the fifth Cleveland player to record a season with at least 25 doubles and 30 steals by his age 24 season, joining Jackson (1911-12), Braggo Roth (1917), Von Hayes (1982) and Sizemore (2007).

Re: Articles

9950
Guardians musings: Tanner Bibee’s rookie year, José Ramírez’s feat, bullpen woes
Image
ANAHEIM, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 10: Tanner Bibee #61 of the Cleveland Guardians pitches in the second inning against the Los Angeles Angels at Angel Stadium of Anaheim on September 10, 2023 in Anaheim, California. (Photo by Meg Oliphant/Getty Images)
By Zack Meisel
Sep 19, 2023

35
Save Article

KANSAS CITY — A batch of musings from Kauffman Stadium, where the Guardians coughed up another late lead on Monday afternoon …
The Rookie of the Year candidate

The back of Tanner Bibee’s baseball card will display, for eternity, a 2.98 ERA and 141 strikeouts in 142 innings for his rookie season. Because of hip inflammation, Bibee won’t make another start this year, but he left his mark.

If not for Orioles infielder Gunnar Henderson, Bibee would be receiving much more Rookie of the Year hype. Henderson is the heavy betting favorite, per BetMGM. No pitcher in either league has won the award since Michael Fulmer with Detroit in 2016.

Terry Francona, on what stands out to him about Bibee’s rookie year:

“In our game, consistency is huge, but saying that, when you’re consistently pretty good, that makes it better. I was consistent. That doesn’t necessarily mean that’s what you’re looking for. I think there’s a lot to like. The kid competes. He’s learning to turn a lineup over, which you don’t see a whole lot in today’s game, especially with young guys. He can pitch to the middle of the order. He seems very durable. I think this kid’s future is really, really bright.”

• Bibee, facing a hitter for the first time in a game: .228/.295/.381 opponent slash line
• Bibee, facing a hitter for the second time in a game: .222/.284/.314 slash line
• Bibee, facing a hitter for the third time in a game: .248/.311/.372 slash line
AL rookie SP with 120+ innings
Tanner Bibee

142

2.98

7.7%

24.1%
Hunter Brown

144

4.68

8.2%

27.4%
Bryce Miller

123

3.88

4.8%

22.6%
Logan Allen

122

3.60

8.8%

22.6%
JP France

128

3.94

7.9%

16.9%

Bibee allowed three runs or fewer in 23 of his 25 starts, including each of his final 16 outings.

In Cleveland, we’ve grown accustomed to starting pitchers breaking into the majors and making the transition look effortless. As one former Cleveland pitcher recently stressed to me: “That’s unique to here.”
The thing that’s difficult to solve

Emmanuel Clase’s 11 blown saves are tied with Frank Funk (1961) for the most in a season in team history. Clase also leads the league with 41 saves. Where there’s opportunity, there’s also opportunity to falter.

The major-league record is 14 blown saves, a distinction shared by Gerry Staley, Rollie Fingers, Bruce Sutter, Bob Stanley and Ron Davis. Five relievers have totaled 11 or more blown saves in the past 25 seasons:

Emmanuel Clase, 2023
Brad Lidge, 2009
Ambiorix Burgos, 2006
Francisco Cordero, 2006
Huston Street, 2006

Clase’s 3.01 ERA is the best of that bunch, as are his 41 saves. In fact, no pitcher has ever recorded 40 or more saves while also totaling 11 blown saves.
Emmanuel Clase has 41 saves in 52 opportunities. (Ron Schwane / Getty Images)

In summary: It’s been a weird year for Clase. Every blown save seems to include some infield chopper that grazes the clouds and results in a hit, an error or both.

So how does he prevent that? With a 100 mph cutter and a devastating slider, he should be able to miss more bats, but his strikeout rate has decreased and opponents’ hard contact has increased. Coaches worked with him in the spring to attack the top of the zone more often, both to induce more swing-and-miss with his cutter and to fool hitters when he followed such a pitch with a slider lower in the zone. That seems to be a work in progress. Clase admitted early in the season that he had to make adjustments to coexist with the pitch clock. He had one of the most deliberate tempos in the league last season.

A couple of stats that tell the story of Clase’s missteps:

• Opponents vs. Clase with runners in scoring position: .319/.337/.385 slash line
• Opponents vs. Clase with the bases empty: .206/.265/.309 slash line

• Opponents vs. Clase when ahead in the count in 2022: .146 average, .460 OPS in 51 plate appearances
• Opponents vs. Clase when ahead in the count in 2023: .339 average, .939 OPS in 80 plate appearances

Trevor Stephan, patroller of the eighth inning, has eight blown saves himself, and his outing on Monday was his third in which he’s allowed four or more runs (though one was unearned).
The most encouraging hitting development

Two of Cleveland’s three most productive hitters this season wear the name Naylor on the back of their uniform.

Josh Naylor’s evolution into a middle-of-the-order threat has been as critical a development as any for a team devoid of offense. His 130 wRC+ (which indicates he’s been 30 percent more productive than a league-average hitter) ranks 10th in the AL. His .311/.351/.502 slash line, 17 home runs, 14.1 percent strikeout rate and resurgence against southpaws — an .834 OPS following an 0-for-17 start this year and an abysmal 2022 season against them — are all reasons for Cleveland’s front office to consider discussing an extension with him in the spring. Naylor can become a free agent after the 2025 season.

Naylor also owns a .969 OPS with runners in scoring position and a .931 OPS in high-leverage situations.

“Josh can hit pretty much anybody’s fastball,” Francona said. “Late in a game, that’s what you’re gonna see a lot.”

And how does he do that? By attempting to swat a machine’s blazing heat.

Naylor said he spent his recovery from an oblique strain standing in against “unrealistic” fastballs in the cage so that when he returned, any pitch tossed in his direction would seem mundane. He stood a few steps closer to the machine so every fastball that whizzed his way looked “like it’s 120 mph,” a way to keep himself humbled, he said.

“I know I’m going to fail on that machine a lot,” he said. “Failure has to be your best friend in this game. You have to be willing to fail and learn from it.”

As for the other half of the Naylor equation, Bo has boosted his wRC+ to 111, with a .333/.434/.635 slash line over the past month.

In 60 big-league games this season, he owns healthy walk and strikeout rates, at 12.1 percent and 23.7 percent, respectively. He also ranks in the 74th percentile in catcher framing and the 70th percentile in pop time.
The stat-sheet stuffer

Players with 216 or more home runs in Cleveland history:

Jim Thome
Albert Belle
Manny Ramirez
Earl Averill
Hal Trosky
Carlos Santana
José Ramírez

With his next homer, Ramírez will pass Trosky and Santana and take over fifth place on the leaderboard.

Players with 200 or more stolen bases in Cleveland history:

Kenny Lofton
Omar Vizquel
Terry Turner
Nap Lajoie
Ray Chapman
Elmer Flick
José Ramírez

That’s seven players on the first list and seven players on the second list. And only one who pops up on both.

Other Ramírez franchise ranks: sixth in doubles, 11th in runs, 13th in hits, fourth in extra-base hits, ninth in total bases.

He’s the 11th player in major-league history with 200 homers and 200 steals through his age-30 season, joining Mike Trout, Alfonso Soriano, Carlos Beltrán, Alex Rodríguez, Sammy Sosa, Barry Bonds, Darryl Strawberry, Andre Dawson, Bobby Bonds and Willie Mays.

Good company.
The power outage

This is far from a new development, but here’s a way to view Cleveland’s lack of thump this season.

The bottom five teams in home runs:

26. Royals, 149
27. Pirates, 146
28. Rockies, 144
29. Nationals, 138
30. Guardians, 116

None of those teams is headed to the postseason.

Last year’s bottom five: Royals, Athletics, Nationals, Guardians, Tigers. Only the Guardians reached the playoffs.

The bottom five in 2021: Rangers, Royals, Marlins, Diamondbacks, Pirates. Those five teams averaged 99 losses.

You get the point. The Guardians have to work so hard to squeeze out a run or two. A nine-run, nine-hit outburst, as they recorded in the fourth inning Sunday afternoon against Texas, is the anomaly of anomalies.

So, how can they flex their muscle more often next season? A full season of the Naylor brothers would help. What Gabriel Arias is capable of over 162 games remains a mystery, but at minimum, he offers some punch in between punchouts. Kyle Manzardo and/or George Valera could provide power in a regular role. Perhaps Jhonkensy Noel or Johnathan Rodriguez or Oscar Gonzalez will contribute some pop. The team could, obviously, benefit from an external acquisition or two.

And, clearly, the Guardians need more offense from the outfield. Outfielders have totaled a league-low 18 home runs, which is less than half the total of the team ahead of them (Nationals, 41).
The reason the horses are returning

This is not a last-ditch effort to complete an implausible AL Central comeback. Shane Bieber and Triston McKenzie are returning to the rotation merely so they can have a normal offseason. And, in Bieber’s case, as he’ll be entering his final season of team control, it might be beneficial for his trade value.

Bieber followed the same routine in 2021 as he worked his way back from a shoulder injury. He made two appearances that September, each a three-inning tease. He then proceeded to a typical offseason program, rather than spend his winter in recovery mode.

There’s enough time remaining to grant each pitcher two starts. Bieber stretched out to 64 pitches in his final minor-league tuneup. McKenzie will make his last start for Triple-A Columbus on Tuesday.
The guy who was ready to walk away

Kole Calhoun had planned to retire if no team had offered him a big-league opportunity by mid-August. His children are 7 and 4, and he felt he was missing out on their lives as he plodded away in Triple A at Scranton and then Oklahoma City. Two weeks before his self-imposed deadline, the Guardians called.

“All I ever wanted was an opportunity this year,” Calhoun said.

His primary motivation was to reach 10 years of big-league service time, a milestone he notched last week. That earns him a fully vested MLB pension and, as The Athletic’s Stephen Nesbitt details here, it’s a treasured feat among player circles. During The Athletic’s interview with Calhoun, José Ramírez interrupted to ask Calhoun how close he was to reaching the 10-year mark.
Kole Calhoun had a .704 OPS (96 OPS+) in his first 34 games with the Guardians. (Frank Jansky / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

“That’s the model career right there,” Will Brennan said. “I want to be a sponge and learn as much as I can from him.”

Along the way, Calhoun realized the example he was setting for younger players who were watching a 35-year-old grind through a season defined by small towns, sparse crowds and a phone that wouldn’t ring. Jason Kipnis, Calhoun’s college teammate at Arizona State, joked with the veteran earlier this month, “You make me want to play again.”

“There was always somebody younger who was watching,” Calhoun said. “It puts everything in perspective that this was always a dream and to get back to where you want to be is rewarding.”

And now, Calhoun said, he can be at peace with wherever his career takes him next, especially if it means more family time.

He noted his daughter, 4, has started to understand his job.

“Why didn’t you hit that?” she’ll ask him.

“I tried to!” he’ll answer.
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain

Re: Articles

9951
“That’s the model career right there,” Will Brennan said. “I want to be a sponge and learn as much as I can from him.”

And this is why Calhoun and Laureano are still with the team.
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain

Re: Articles

9953
That was another excellent article by Meisel. His Clase stats are very interesting. His confirmation statistically of the extraordinary consistancy by Bibee really establishes how impressive and confident a pitcher he is. Especially impressed by these:
Bibee, facing a hitter for the first time in a game: .228/.295/.381 opponent slash line
• Bibee, facing a hitter for the second time in a game: .222/.284/.314 slash line
• Bibee, facing a hitter for the third time in a game: .248/.311/.372 slash line
Williams has higher expections, but has been more typical of an excellent rookie, with many solid starts, some stumbies and often too many pitches thrown.

Re: Articles

9954
Yes there are some viable internal offensive candidates for 2024. For a very rare occasion we have a bunch of power bats in AAA.
Are any of them ready?
Rodriguez 29 homers total; stats overall were at least as good for Columbus as for Akron. Not yet on the 40 man roster. He has a RF arm. Has been described as an Oscar Gonzalez with more [but not a lot more] selectivity.
Noel 27 homers playing all year in AAA at a young age, 22. He's played mostly OF but he's not a solid outifielder. Also K's a lot and walks more than I'd have expected.
Valera was supposed to be on the major league club well before this. After a recurrence of his hand injury he came back very ineffictively; he had a couple solid weeks n August. Will never hit for high average but takes plenty of walks
Kyle Manzardo: he could be decisive. In his small sample with Columbus [greatly improved over his time in Rays' AAA uniform] he's been outstanding:
71-16-20-16. the 20 hits breakdown: 8 doubles, 6 homers, 6 singles. 11 walks, 14 strikeouts. 378/648 Unlike the other noted he's a 1B who will share the corner and DH with Naylor.

Re: Articles

9955
It goes without saying that Cleveland has a much better record of immediate impact from pitchers then hitters.

So if it were me I would do JUST what they did last offseason when they signed Josh Bell. That still seems a good move to me - unlucky it didn't work out.

So get a veteran bat like that and roll with that and roll over the rest from this year.

Bo Naylor should be another bat for a full year. Certainly reason to believe Gimenez (who finally got his head outta his butt offensively) can step it up.


The pitching should be good....and deep.
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain

Re: Articles

9957
Agree rusty or at the very least reducing his role to 4th outfielder/defensive replacement/pinch runner (especially in 10th inning)
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain

Re: Articles

9958
When I look through the roster I have to agree with you two. To a degree they've already done that work with Kyle Manzardo ready to hit the majors with his solid bat for DH. For OF the AAA guys are interesting but I'd want a veteran out there, too.

Bullpen needs some new arms. Or maybe some veteran arms. The Brian Shaw role wasn't filled this year until Lopez a couple of weeks ago Terry Pluto makes the case too for signing him on.

Re: Articles

9959
The Athletic re-grades deadline deals; I'll excerpt all references to our 3 moves

Tampa Bay made an intriguing challenge trade, giving up contact-focused minor-league first baseman Kyle Manzardo for Guardians pitcher Aaron Civale. Some within the sport thought the Rays might be buying the dip with Civale, who was in the midst of a career year. But the Rays also simply required pitching depth as the club absorbed a slew of injuries. Civale hasn’t been as good as he was in the first half, but he’s been decent: A 4.43 ERA but a 3.31 fielding-independent ERA in eight starts with the Rays. He has completed the sixth inning once for Tampa Bay. Odds are, he won’t be asked to go much more than five in any postseason outing, either. — AM
Trade deadline re-grade: B-

Dodgers . "Amed Rosario has been disappointing"

"The Marlins have benefited from an uptick from Bell, who often plays a portion of his season as Dr. Jekyll and a portion as Mr. Hyde."

Re: Articles

9960
Do we include post-deadline waiver claims in our grades? (Hold on, checking with an editor … ) In any case, the Guardians had a bizarre deadline. In retrospect, their collection of moves seemed like a white flag. They sent Amed Rosario to the Dodgers for Noah Syndergaard, off-loading a pending free agent, in part, because they needed arms after trading Aaron Civale to the Tampa Rays for top prospect Kyle Manzardo. (They also dealt Josh Bell to Miami for prospect Kahlil Watson and veteran Jean Segura.)

The weirdest part was they then hopped into the Angels’ waivers sweepstakes and claimed basically everyone. The only downside, of course, was money spent, and it was a Hail Mary that didn’t work.

Civale’s numbers in Tampa Bay have been fine despite him having slightly better peripheral numbers than he had in Cleveland, while the acquisition of Manzardo was a play for 2024 and beyond. The Guardians quickly fell out of contention after the deadline, which might have been the result of dealing Civale. But one could also argue the Cleveland front office correctly evaluated their team and rightfully sold. In the end, it’s still too early to grade this deadline. But that won’t stop us. — RD

Trade deadline re-grade: B