Jack Hannahan's RBI single ends 16-inning marathon as Cleveland Indians top Oakland, 4-3
Published: Wednesday, August 31, 2011, 11:59 PM Updated: Thursday, September 01, 2011, 7:40 AM
By Paul Hoynes, The Plain Dealer The Plain Dealer
Umpire Bruce Dreckman has a close eye on the play as Cord Phelps slides toward the plate and Oakland catcher Kurt Suzuki tries to make the tag in the 16th inning early Thursday morning at Progressive Field. Dreckman ruled Phelps safe, as the Indians pulled out a 4-3 victory.
CLEVELAND, Ohio --
The midges returned to Progressive Field. Not in their Joba Chamberlain-like fury, but they were back nonetheless Wednesday night.
Were they a harbinger of the postseason? Or did they just come to hang out?
Turns out they were fast asleep by the time the Indians beat Oakland, 4-3, in 16 innings to reclaim second place in the AL Central. It was the longest game of the season for both teams. Jack Hannahan won it with a game-winning single after hitting two homers earlier in the game.
Jim Thome started the winning rally with a long single to left with one out off Josh Outman. Cord Phelps pinch-ran and went to second on Carlos Santana's single. Hannahan ended it with a single to right as Phelps scored the game-winner with a head-first slide.
"I was just trying to stay up the middle," Hannahan said. "To be honest with you I didn't think about swinging away (for another homer). Those hits had happened so long ago in that game that I forgot what happened."
David DeJesus got to the ball quickly and his strong throw was in time to catcher Kurt Suzuki, but a little up the third-base line and a bit high.
"It was close, but I think I got my hand in there," said Phelps, even if other Indians privately thought otherwise.
Third-base coach Steve Smith came over to Phelps' locker while he was talking to reporters and said, "Cord, thanks for the great slide or all these guys would be in front of my locker talking to me."
It was the Indians' 17th last-at-bat victory at home. They are 22-16 in games decided in the last at-bat this season.
The two teams combined for 34 strikeouts -- 15 by Indians pitchers and 19 by the Athletics -- for the most ever recorded in a single game at Progressive Field. Indians center fielder Ezequiel Carrera was the only starter on either team not to strike out.
The win went to Frank Herrmann (4-0), who retired 12 straight in four perfect innings of relief. Outman (3-4) was the loser.
"This convinces me that this might be our year," Herrmann said. "You see those 'What If' commercials. We keep pulling out games in this kind of fashion. Who knows, maybe this is our year. Things are falling into place for us or we're making them fall into place."
"Our bullpen was unbelievable -- again," said Manny Acta, who will need a long effort from Fausto Carmona in a noon start today. "Chad Durbin made some fantastic pitches. Frank Herrmann was the hero. He was perfect out there. He was the last guy out there. I didn't want to bring Rafael Perez in that game."
Acta said the Indians will call up one or two relievers from Class AAA Columbus for Thursday's game. Big league rosters can be expanded on Thursday.
"Our bullpen did great, but got hurt (10 scoreless innings) so we're probably going to have some reinforcements here for Thursday," said Acta. "But no names."
Jason Donald hit a leadoff double in the 15th to end a streak of 24 straight outs by the A's bullpen. Donald went to third on Jerad Head's fly ball to the track in left, but Outman struck out Lou Marson, walked Carrera and struck out Kosuke Fukudome.
The A's loaded the bases in the 12th with one out, but Chad Durbin struck out Ryan Sweeney and retired DeJesus on a pop up. Sweeney came into the game hitting .667 (6-for-9) against the Indians this year.
The Indians are 6-6 in extra inning games this season. This was their third extra inning game in August that lasted 14 or more innings.
Hannahan's second homer pulled the Indians in a 3-3 tie in the sixth inning. Hannahan sent Rich Harden's 0-1 pitch off the foul pole with one out. It was the 3,000th homer hit in the 1,400th game at Progressive Field. It gave Hannahan three in the last two games after he went homerless for over two months.
Hannahan hit .420 (21-for-50) in August. "I've never had a month like this," he said.
The Indians finished August at 15-13. It's the first time they didn't have a losing record in a month since going 14-12 in May.
With the victory the Indians stayed 5 1/2 games behind first-place Detroit, while moving past Chicago and into second place in the AL Central. The White Sox lost to the Twins.
The Indians are 6-4 on the longest homestand of the season which ends today. They have won five of their last six games and improved to 5-1 against Oakland this year.
After Hannahan's second homer, the Indians offense didn't do much. Lou Marson hit a leadoff single in the seventh and moved to third on a sacrifice bunt and ground out, but Asdrubal Cabrera flied out to the track against Grant Balfour.
Hideki Matsui opened the 10th with a single off Joe Smith. Coco Crisp pinch ran and stole second for his 38th steal of the season and Oakland's fourth of the game. Smith struck out Brandon Allen and ended the inning when Ryan Sweeney grounded into a double play.
Suzuki gave the A's a 3-2 lead in with a homer off Ubaldo Jimenez to break a 2-2 tie. After a strong start against Kansas City, Jimenez needed 82 pitches to get through the first four innings before finding the strike zone. Jimenez left after six innings. He allowed three runs on six hits with two walks and six strikeouts.
Ubaldo's pitch count made for an early exit. Jimenez threw 114 pitches, 70 for strikes. He struck out six of the last seven A's he faced.
Harden left after six as well with a similar line: six innings, three runs, six hits, two walks and six strikeouts. He threw only 93 pitches, 57 for strikes.
The Indians took a 1-0 lead in the first when Carrera opened with a triple to the wall in center and scored on Fukudome's sacrifice fly. It was Fukudome's 13th RBI in 31 games for the Indians. He had 13 in 87 games for the Cubs before the Indians acquired him on July 27.
The A's made it 1-1 in the second when Jimenez walked Scott Sizemore with the bases loaded.
Hannahan started the second with a homer to center to make it 2-2. Harden found himself after that. He held the Indians to one run on three hits through the sixth.