Kenny Mathews (Photo: Jesse Piecuch)
Scouting the Indians 2013 Draft: Part 5
By Tony Lastoria
October 4, 2013
Share This
Over the course of the past few weeks I have been posting post-draft pieces like this on all of the players that the Indians drafted and signed from the 2013 Draft. The Indians signed 24 players in total and also signed two undrafted free agents, and I have comments on each and every player from Indians Amateur Scouting Director Brad Grant.
In this final piece I once again include comments from Grant and a quick summary on each player as well as any stats from the 2013 season.
Rather than just roll down the list of players in order of when they were picked, I have posted these with players at random and mixed the higher and lower profile prospects together. Five players have been featured in each article for a total of five post-draft capsules, though in this piece there are six since I profile the final four drafted players and the two undrafted players.
Here are the other pieces posted in this series:
Part 1: Clint Frazier, Thomas Pannone, Silento Sayles, Matt Whitehouse, Shane Rowland
Part 2: Kyle Crockett, James Roberts, Grant Fink, Cortland Cox, Mike Giuffre
Part 3: Casey Shane, Adam Plutko, Sicnarf Loopstok, Cole Sulser, Justin Garcia
Part 4: Dace Kime, Trevor Frank, Paul Hendrix, Kerry Doane, Jordan Milbrath
Sean Brady (Left-handed Pitcher): 5th round, Ida S Baker High School (FL)
2013 stats: 10 GS, 0-1, 1.97 ERA, 32.0 IP, 24 H, 11 R (7 ER), 2 HR, 6 BB, 30 K, .205 BAA
Quick Summary:
Brady was the first prep player the Indians selected in the 2013 Draft and had a commitment to the University of Florida. He is in the low 90s with his fastball and gets it up to 93 MPH, and saw a big spike in his velocity from his junior season in high school to this past season. He mixes in a curveball and changeup that could both at least be average offerings - the curveball is a plus offering and his out pitch. He is a smaller left-hander along the lines of Indians’ 2011 draft pick lefty Shawn Morimando, so the small size brings some concern about his ability to start down the road.
Brad Grant:
“He got off to a really good start, and it does mean something to go out and compete right away. It is a big adjustment going from high school to professional baseball learning how to pitch every fifth day and learning how to use all of your pitches and he was able to do that quickly. I think that is one of the biggest things about Sean is he has an advanced feel to pitch and he has an advanced understanding of how to pitch for a high school kid. He also comes with some stuff too as he will throw 88-91 MPH with his fastball, he has a chance for a plus curveball, has a good feel for his changeup, and he can really throw strikes and locate his pitches well. He is a guy for a high school kid who has a chance to move quickly and is very polished for what he does and has a very good understanding for what he does. He is a little bit further ahead than where Shawn Morimando was coming out of high school, but they are very similar in terms of their ability to pitch, makeup and their understanding of what they are trying to do out there. I think Sean is a little more advanced with where his breaking ball was than where Morimando’s was coming out of high school, but both are very similar and have a chance to have some success at the major league level in the future.”
Kenny Mathews (Left-handed Pitcher): 7th round, Riverside Community College (CA)
2013 stats: 12 GS, 0-3, 2.52 ERA, 39.1 IP, 35 H, 15 R (11 ER), 0 HR, 13 BB, 37 K, .233 BAA
Quick Summary:
Mathews had a great start to his college career last year at Cal-State Fullerton, but transferred to Riverside CC this past season. He struggled with a lat injury in college this season and it affected his performance and sidelined him for a short time. He does not throw hard at all as he barely touches the high 80s, but he has a nice build, good pitchability, and has a good breaking ball and a changeup that is a plus offering. He has a good feel for his pitches with plus control, so it will be interesting to see how he translates to the pro game going forward as a command-control pitcher.
Brad Grant:
“He had a really good pro debut. He went out and performed at Mahoning Valley in a league that is tough offensively. He maintained a 45ish type fastball pitching at 88-89 MPH, but he really knows how to locate it and can throw it to both sides of the plate. He is another guy who has an advanced feel to pitch. He has two solid average secondary pitches in his curveball and changeup, and has a good delivery. He is another guy that needs to add some strength as he goes along and as that strength comes we could see a little bit more fastball velocity there. I think he has a very good delivery and some good arm action. He has a lot of things that will allow velocity to come, but even if he doesn’t get the velocity and pitches where he is right now at 88-89 MPH he has a good feel to pitch and a really advanced feel to locate his fastball to both sides and change eye levels with it. He can pitch effectively in that 88-89 range, but at the same time as he advances in our system and gets stronger and adds strength I think he will add some velocity too.”
Ben Heller (Right-handed Pitcher): 22nd round, Olivet Nazarene University (IL)
2013 stats: 21 G, 1-3, 3.13 ERA, 37.1 IP, 37 H, 16 R (13 ER), 0 HR, 14 BB, 39 K, .252 BAA
Quick Summary:
Heller is a college senior signing who is a depth signing that can fill several roles for the Indians. He has been a starter all four years in college but will likely pitch out of the bullpen in the minors due to the lack of a third pitch and more priority to other pitchers in a starting role. Even though he is a depth pen arm at the moment, his fastball is very intriguing as he gets it into the upper 90s. His secondary stuff is inconsistent, but if his slider or changeup come along he could be a sleeper bullpen prospect for the Indians.
Brad Grant:
“He is just a lean right-handed pitcher that was 21-years old and a college senior, but who still has some upside to him. The fastball is obviously what we liked as it is 95-96 MPH with some life to it. The changeup is a split change and is ahead of the slider, and the slider is a pitch he still has to develop. There is still some upside to him, especially if we can develop that slider to be a little bit sharper and harder. But throwing 95-96 MPH is something good to work with. He throws strikes and threw strikes in college too. There are some delivery things that help his deception, but at the same time there are some things we can do delivery-wise to help him. There is something still there especially since he is from a small school in Illinois and only 21.”
Garrett Smith (Infielder): 37th round, Cal Lutheran University (CA)
2013 stats: 20 G, .070 AVG, 8 R, 0 2B, 0 3B, 0 HR, 1 RBI, 7 BB, 11 K, 0 SB, .242 OPS
Quick Summary:
There is some pedigree to the pro game as Smith’s father is former Indians coach Steve Smith. He was not a regular starter until his senior year at California Lutheran. He managed to break in as a starter as a junior and really improved as a senior. While he offers up a lot of versatility, the bat is a big question mark as he has minimal to no power and does not make much hard contact. He is another organizational guy who can be a backup/utility guy for the team.
Brad Grant:
“He is the son of Steve Smith, our third base coach last year, so he has some pedigree with his background. He is a lean switch-hitter and another guy who can move around and play third, short and second. He has some tools to be able to move around the infield and provide some depth around the infield.”
Cody Ferrell (Outfielder): Undrafted free agent, Oklahoma City University
2013 stats: 49 G, .268 AVG, 21 R, 3 2B, 0 3B, 1 HR, 6 RBI, 12 BB, 34 K, 0 SB, .653 OPS
Quick Summary:
When the Indians released Tyler Booth at the end of June, they picked up Ferrell and he did a solid job filling in as a role player in the lower levels. He has some versatility in the outfield as he can play all three spots and while he does not have much power he is a gamer who puts up a quality at bat. He is a guy who accepts his role in the organization, which will make some friends with the player development staff and could help him stick around for a while and potentially provide time for his value to increase.
Brad Grant:
“He is a center fielder, and the primary thing is he can get on base. He can run a little bit and move around to left and right field. He plays the leadoff game to get on base, will take a walk and has a pretty good knowledge of the strike zone.”
Gerald Bautista (Outfielder): Undrafted free agent, George M. Steinbrenner HS (FL)
2013 stats: 41 G, .256 AVG, 18 R, 7 2B, 1 3B, 0 HR, 15 RBI, 18 BB, 36 K, 1 SB, .686 OPS
Quick summary:
The Indians signed him as a non-drafted free agent out of high school and he is the son of former major leaguer Danny Bautista. He is viewed as more of a corner infielder, though could mix in some at second base. Even though he was undrafted out of high school, he has a little bit of pop in his bat and has a little more polish and baseball experience than some of the recent Latin American signings his age.
Brad Grant:
“He is another guy who played all three infield spots. He is a solid average fielder with solid average arm strength. He is an average runner who can move around between second, short and third and provide that utility depth. He has some projection with the bat; it still has to come a little bit but he has a good chance to hit in the future.”
Follow Tony and the Indians Prospect Insider on Twitter @TonyIBI. Also, his new book the 2013 Cleveland Indians Baseball Insider which profiles the Indians' Top 100 Prospects and more is available for sale.