Cleveland Indians endure beanball melee, Royals' comeback for 11-9 triumph in 10 innings
Updated: Sunday, April 15, 2012, 1:22 AM
Paul Hoynes, The Plain Dealer
Charlie Riedel, Associated Press Kansas City center fielder Jarrod Dyson can't leap high enough to prevent Shin-Soo Choo's tiebreaking two-run double in the 10th inning of Saturday's game at Kauffman Stadium.
Kansas City, Mo. -- The boos didn't bother Shin-Soo Choo. He pretended like he was back home at Progressive Field.
Get it? Choo sounds a lot like boo.
In the 10th inning, Choo turned the boos to silence with a two-run double to give the Indians an 11-9 victory over Kansas City in a game that saw Indians manager Manny Acta, starting pitcher Jeanmar Gomez and third baseman Jack Hannahan ejected in a brawl-filled third inning.
The problem started in the third. Really, the problem started last year, but that's getting ahead of the story.
The Indians were just starting a five-run inning against lefty Jonathan Sanchez on Saturday when he hit Choo on the right knee. Sanchez, pitching for the Giants at the time, hit Choo on June 24 and shattered his left thumb. He was on the disabled list for six weeks.
"I was thinking about that when I came to the plate against him," said Choo, who has been hit three times this year.
Sanchez hit Choo with a fastball. Choo was not happy. He shouted at Sanchez and pointed his bat toward the plate.
"I told him to throw it over the plate," said Choo.
Both teams came onto the field, with Hannahan leading the charge.
"I don't know how many times Sanchez is going to hit Choo, but the last time he did he has three screws in his thumb," said Hannahan. "If we're going to contend, we need our big boys healthy."
It wasn't visible from the press box, but plate umpire and crew chief Gary Darling issued a warning to both benches. It did not prevent Gomez from hitting Mike Moustakas, Kansas City's first hitter in the bottom of the third, to empty the benches again. Gomez and Acta were immediately ejected.
Hannahan charged into a scrum of Royals players near first base before being restrained. When the field was cleared a second time, Acta led Hannahan off the field.
Gomez hasn't been around the big leagues that long, but he knew enough to say he didn't intentionally throw at Moustakas.
"I was just trying to open the inside corner so I could work the outside part of the plate again him," Gomez said.
Said Hannahan: "This is the way baseball has been played for a long time. You hit our studs. We hit your studs. That's the way it's always been played and that's the way it should be played."
Hannahan felt Sanchez intentionally hit Choo, but Choo did not think it was intentional.
Gomez and Hannahan will probably be suspended. Ubaldo Jimenez returns to the rotation today to face the Royals after serving a five-game suspension of his own.
Acta said the situation will be addressed with Gomez.
"I believe he was trying to protect his teammates, but I think he went overboard a little," Acta said. "First of all, there was a warning in place. Once you hit a guy, you're going to be thrown out. That early in a game, you tax the bullpen.
"We were blessed to have Josh Tomlin to suck up some of those innings."
After the third, Choo was booed by the crowd of 21,788 whenever he came to the plate.
"That doesn't bother me," he said. "In Cleveland, the fans say 'Choo.' It sounds the same here."
Jason Donald and Jason Kipnis set the table for Choo's big two-out hit with consecutive singles to start the 10th off Greg Holland (0-1).
Chris Perez retired the side in order in the 10th for his second save. Jairo Asencio (1-1) earned his first big-league win with a scoreless ninth and a big assist from catcher Carlos Santana, who threw out swift Jarrod Dyson on an attempted steal of second for the first out.
The Indians came out of their half of the third with a 5-0 lead. Jose Lopez's two-run double was the big hit of the inning. It also included a sacrifice fly by Donald, the first by the Indians this year.
The Royals made it 5-2 with two runs in the third. Alcides Escobar tripled home Moustakas and then scored on Dyson's sacrifice fly.
Cabrera doubled and Santana singled to give the Tribe a 6-2 lead in the fourth. The Indians made it 9-2 as Casey Kotchman and Kipnis homered in the fifth.
The Royals, however, kept coming.
They scored twice in the fifth on a Moustakas double and a double-play grounder by Escobar to make it 9-4. Tomlin came out for the sixth, but couldn't get through the inning as his defense gave the Royals five outs instead of three.
Jeff Francoeur singled and scored on Billy Butler's double. Tomlin retired Alex Gordon for the second out, but Donald threw wide of first base on Yuniesky Betancourt's grounder to third to keep the inning going.
Lefty Rafael Perez relieved to face Moustakas. Perez, never throwing above 82 mph, gave up an RBI double to make it 9-6. Joe Smith relieved to get the final out of the inning.
Smith started the seventh, but left with one out and Dyson on second following a leadoff double. Tony Sipp relieved and gave up an RBI double to Eric Hosmer. Butler followed with a single to center to make it 9-8.
Yuniesky Betancourt's leadoff homer in the eighth off Vinnie Pestano pulled the Royals into a 9-9 tie.