By Jim Ingraham
JIngraham@News-Herald.com
@jitribeinsider
Let's call them The Goodyear Seven.
They are Felix Pie, Russ Canzler, Aaron Cunningham, Ryan Spilborghs, Fred Lewis, Shelley Duncan and Matt LaPorta.
That's the cattle call of candidates the Indians brought with them to spring training in order to find a left fielder for the 2012 championship season.
Five games into the season, the Indians have pushed aside the whole mob and signed 38-year-old Johnny Damon as the club's newest left fielder du jour.
If you want perhaps the most revealing barometer that best reflects the Indians' systematic demise as an American League powerhouse from the late 1990s until now, look at the evolution of the left-field position.
It goes something like this: from Albert Belle to David Justice to Ellis Burks to Matt Lawton to Coco Crisp to Jason Michaels to David Dellucci to Ben Francisco to Michael Brantley to Austin Kearns to The Goodyear Seven.
Go ahead, connect the dots.
It is not a pretty picture.
Left field is supposed to be a big-time run-producing position. Not for the Indians. In recent years, the production they've gotten out of that position has instead resembled what you might get from a second baseman.
Indians officials counter with the argument that they are getting above-the-norm production from their shortstop and catcher — two positions that typically profile as second- or third-tier offensive positions — so that makes up for the lack of production from left field.
That's true to a certain extent, but why not aim higher than that? Why not aspire to have above-average production from your shortstop and catcher and also from your left fielder?
This is why: the Indians' player development system hasn't developed an impact home-grown left fielder since Belle, who was drafted in 1987 — think about that! — and they don't have the financial wherewithal to make it not matter by going out and signing a big-ticket, big-bat, free-agent left fielder.
So they have to cut and paste.
Which is what they've done in left field for most of the last mostly declining 15 years.
Which leads to situations such as they had this spring, when they brought a cluster of fringe major leaguers to training camp and hoped to catch lightning in a bottle with one of them.
That didn't happen, not surprisingly, so five games into the season, with their offense looking DOA in the season-opening homestand, the Indians went into scramble mode, which led to the acquisition of Damon — a 38-year-old Band-Aid.
He is not being asked to throw the Indians on his back and carry them to the postseason. Best-case scenario: he makes the offense incrementally better, and brings some leadership and experience to the team.
The irony of it all is that this year and next year comprise a two-year window for winning, in the judgment of Indians officials. Teams who are "going for it" don't normally have a revolving door at such an important offensive position as left field.
That's not to say it can't be done. It's only to say that it's a bit unusual. The Indians have the makings of an above-average pitching staff, and teams with that generally are able to stay in the vicinity of contention for most of the season.
However, teams in contention from year to year tend to have huge payrolls, or a consistent player development system, able to fill most of the holes on the major-league roster when needed.
That's where the Indians' model breaks down. Their last homegrown impact left fielder was drafted a quarter of a century ago.
Nobody said this is easy. It's hard to build a really good baseball team. You need money. You need really good baseball decision makers, and you need some luck.
Teams that have all three are tough to stop. The good news for the Indians is that there aren't many teams that have all three. That's also the bad news for the Indians, because they are one of the have-nots.
So Damon is here for now, with one of three likely outcomes to his arrival.
1. He'll play well and the Indians will stay in contention all year.
2. He'll play well, but the Indians will fall out of contention and they will trade him at midseason, for a marginal prospect.
3. He'll play like many 38-year olds play, won't make much of a difference either way, and will be gone if and when Grady Sizemore returns, or if and when the Indians decide to move on and look at another member of The Goodyear Seven.
In case you're wondering, the left fielder at Triple-A Columbus is Ryan Spilborghs. [actually last night it was Matt Laporta, until he was hit by a pitch and left the game, replaced by Ryan S]
Try to contain yourself.