Cleveland Sports Forum

Wouldn't be surprised.

Count me in on one not very pleased with the Gimenez / Naylor salary dumps.

Why is this team forever on the cheap? since 2000, we had 3 season where the payroll topped 100 mil, 2017, 2018 & 2019. This year should be one of them). Especially now when we're knocking on the door.

We had a legitimate shot at going to the series in 2025. Those odds just slipped a few notches.

Detroit came close and so did Kansas City in 2024. Minnesota was in it right up until the end. It's going to be that much tougher to win the division much less heading to the World Series in 2025. This was not the right time to dump Gimenez or Naylor or their production.

Better hope that Ramirez does not have any prolonged slumps (which is not out of the realm of possibility).

There is no way in hell that we have anyone in the organization that is going to make up for the loss in production between Naylor and Gimenez. We needed additions and not subtractions.

I was po'd when we traded Lindor when we could have had the best keystone combination in baseball along side Ramirez. I'm sick to think we had that same chance in 2025 with Gimenez and Rocchio. Not often you get this kind of opportunity just when the two were fitting together like a hand in glove.

I'm reading where Gimenez's production has slipped the past two seasons. This year, Gimenez had 21 runs saved on defense. He averaged 21 the last 3 season.

In 2024, Gimenez had 63 ribis, 22 doubles, a triple, 9 homer and 30 stolen bases. I can only dream where Gimenez's replacement can put up those kinds of numbers.

In ridding ourselves of Gimenez and Naylor, we lose not only major league experience but also playoff experience on the grandest stage. Their replacements most likely will have little major league experience much less playoff experience. Sorry folks, but, in my opinion, we shot ourselves in the foot.

Will Naylor's replacement put up Naylor-like numbers, like 31 homers and 108 rbis???? Personally, I don't think so.

You can't lose that much production and expect to win. It took a lot of gears to mesh last year. Can one expect the same one more year?

What did we really gain during the wnter meetngs? A number 2/3 starting pitcher???

Could give a crap about the minor leaguers we picked up. Yeah, they may develop into decent players 3 years down the road. I was looking more at tomorrow. Our window of opportunity is 2025. It should have been 2024. I'm getting pretty tired of looking at what will happen in the future when the opportunity is now.

<

Did I miss a Naylor trade ? Did not think so. The imaginary Naylor trade post is almost as bad as your take on the Giminez trade. Giminez for a #2 or #3 starter with 4 years of contract control is a great trade.

We have players that can play 2nd. We do not have enough controllable contract starting pitchers. Saving 10 million is just a bonus.

GEEZ !

I love Giminez's defense; could be one of the best ever at his relays.
But we have 2nd basemen of quality just behind him so a trade was inevitable sooner or later
Ortiz has the look of a solid addition to the rotation well ahead of his arbitration years.
If we were deep in major league pitching the trade might have been delayed a year.

Agree.

I guess I blew the Naylor call.

Tried to find the article I was reading concerning Horwitz. Can't find it.

Still doesn't soften the blow of losing Gimenez. I still don't think we have anyone to replace Gimenez in the near future, like next year. Gimenez's experience was invaluable. It's also the intangibles that will be even harder to replace. This has to be a shock to Rocchio. ;The two formed a close bond.

Time to make a run at Roki Susaki. What's to lose?

<