Re: Articles
Posted: Tue Mar 04, 2025 3:14 pm
Cleveland Guardians Opening Day roster projection 2.0
MIAMI, FLORIDA - JUNE 09: Gabriel Arias #13 of the Cleveland Guardians celebrates with teammates after hitting a home run against the Miami Marlins during the second inning at loanDepot park on June 09, 2024 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by Rich Storry/Getty Images)
By Zack Meisel
Mar 4, 2025
We’re under a month to Opening Day. Which 26 players will the Guardians bring to Kansas City? Here’s the latest forecast.
Catchers (2): Bo Naylor, Austin Hedges
Others in camp: Jake Anchia, Kody Huff, Cooper Ingle, Dom Nuñez
No surprises here. The Guardians are bullish on a Naylor breakout at the plate, and Hedges is his backup. After that, well, Nuñez would be the break-glass-in-case-of-emergency option; he assisted the club during the playoffs last season as an extra body to catch bullpen sessions. The organization is high on its minor-league catching depth, especially relative to where it stood a few years ago. Ingle has a promising bat, Huff is well-regarded defensively and they’re excited to watch Jacob Cozart, their second-round pick last summer out of North Carolina State.
A lot is riding this year, though, on Naylor rediscovering the bat that tormented opposing pitchers for the last six weeks of the 2023 season.
Infielders (7): José Ramírez, Brayan Rocchio, Gabriel Arias, Tyler Freeman, Carlos Santana, Kyle Manzardo, Daniel Schneemann
Others in camp: Juan Brito, Dayan Frias, David Fry, Angel Martínez, Micah Pries, Milan Tolentino, Yordys Valdes, Kahlil Watson, Will Wilson
First base, shortstop, third base and designated hitter are set, more or less. But there’s a crowd vying for the second-base gig, and at least one, and probably two of those who don’t win the job will win roster spots anyway. We’ll go, for now, with Arias as the Opening Day second baseman, and that’ll mean Brito opens the year in Columbus until the Guardians can find him regular playing time at the big-league level. Freeman’s versatility earns him a spot, and here’s guessing the club opts for Schneemann so Martínez can play every day at Triple A, rather than waste away on the major-league bench.
Not only might this second base/utility player(s) arrangement change by the opener, but it could very well reshuffle several times during the season, perhaps paving the way for Brito or, late this summer, top prospect Travis Bazzana.
Outfielders (4): Steven Kwan, Lane Thomas, Will Brennan, Jhonkensy Noel
Others in camp: Chase DeLauter, Petey Halpin, Johnathan Rodriguez, George Valera
Since all of the second-base candidates can shift to the outfield, this is rather simple. Kwan and Thomas will occupy left and center, respectively. Brennan and Noel figure to split right-field duties, unless someone can crash the party. DeLauter’s delayed start to spring action makes it unlikely he breaks camp with the club. If he stays healthy, DeLauter is primed for a big-league audition, but the first word of this sentence is awfully important.
If the club needs a right-handed stick at some point, Rodriguez is ready for a look. If the club needs a left-handed stick at some point, Valera could be an option.
Starting pitchers (5): Tanner Bibee, Luis Ortiz, Gavin Williams, Ben Lively, Triston McKenzie
Others in camp: Kolby Allard, Logan Allen, Shane Bieber, Joey Cantillo, Slade Cecconi, Will Dion, Daniel Espino, John Means, Doug Nikhazy, Vince Velasquez, Ryan Webb
Don’t just look at spring training statistics. Don’t just look at spring training statistics. Don’t just look at spr—
OK, the starting pitching performances have been, uh, a bit shaky thus far. But it’s always more about those spring clichés — how the ball is coming out of a pitcher’s hand, whether they’re attacking the zone and repeating their delivery, if they’re putting in the work each and every day — than stats from a handful of innings of work.
The Guardians have a lot of different scenarios to consider. For instance, Lively and McKenzie are out of minor-league options. They won’t be going to Triple-A Columbus; it’s either the rotation, the bullpen or another team for them. Velasquez and Allard, as veteran non-roster invitees, have opt-out clauses and some authority over where they wind up.
McKenzie’s last outing — in which he walked five and recorded only two outs — offered a vivid reminder of his struggles from last season. Would a trip to the bullpen to begin the season help him? That could open a spot for Allen or Cecconi or one of the veterans. There’s still time for the starters to round into form, but the ultimate Opening Day setup could remain a question mark for a few weeks, especially since there’s a bit of unrest in the bullpen.
Relievers (8): Emmanuel Clase, Hunter Gaddis, Tim Herrin, Cade Smith, Paul Sewald, Andrew Walters, Jakob Junis, Kolby Allard
Others in camp: Franco Aleman, Tanner Burns, Nic Enright, Luis Frías, Bradley Hanner, Sam Hentges, Mason Hickman, Zak Kent, Jack Leftwich, Andrew Misiaszek, Parker Mushinski, Erik Sabrowski, Trevor Stephan
Several things can be true at once about this group. One, Cleveland’s bullpen has a shot to repeat as the most proficient bullpen in the league. Two, there’s undoubtedly some regression on the horizon; can all of Clase, Smith, Gaddis and Herrin post sub-2.00 ERAs again? Seems impossible. Three, there’s plenty of depth to compensate for some of that regression, even after the team traded Nick Sandlin and Eli Morgan and cut ties with Pedro Avila. Four, that depth is looking a bit shaky at the moment, thanks to a rash of injuries.
They’re taking extra care with Sabrowski, who completed his first full season in 2024 following a pair of Tommy John surgeries. Hentges is out for the year following shoulder surgery. Aleman will miss the start of the season because of surgery to repair a hernia. Enright is dealing with a lat strain. Stephan is working his way back from elbow surgery.
So, we’ll go with Allard, presuming the Guardians want a second left-hander on the staff in addition to Herrin. But they also could spin the reliever roulette wheel and go with Mushinski.

By Zack Meisel
Mar 4, 2025
We’re under a month to Opening Day. Which 26 players will the Guardians bring to Kansas City? Here’s the latest forecast.
Catchers (2): Bo Naylor, Austin Hedges
Others in camp: Jake Anchia, Kody Huff, Cooper Ingle, Dom Nuñez
No surprises here. The Guardians are bullish on a Naylor breakout at the plate, and Hedges is his backup. After that, well, Nuñez would be the break-glass-in-case-of-emergency option; he assisted the club during the playoffs last season as an extra body to catch bullpen sessions. The organization is high on its minor-league catching depth, especially relative to where it stood a few years ago. Ingle has a promising bat, Huff is well-regarded defensively and they’re excited to watch Jacob Cozart, their second-round pick last summer out of North Carolina State.
A lot is riding this year, though, on Naylor rediscovering the bat that tormented opposing pitchers for the last six weeks of the 2023 season.
Infielders (7): José Ramírez, Brayan Rocchio, Gabriel Arias, Tyler Freeman, Carlos Santana, Kyle Manzardo, Daniel Schneemann
Others in camp: Juan Brito, Dayan Frias, David Fry, Angel Martínez, Micah Pries, Milan Tolentino, Yordys Valdes, Kahlil Watson, Will Wilson
First base, shortstop, third base and designated hitter are set, more or less. But there’s a crowd vying for the second-base gig, and at least one, and probably two of those who don’t win the job will win roster spots anyway. We’ll go, for now, with Arias as the Opening Day second baseman, and that’ll mean Brito opens the year in Columbus until the Guardians can find him regular playing time at the big-league level. Freeman’s versatility earns him a spot, and here’s guessing the club opts for Schneemann so Martínez can play every day at Triple A, rather than waste away on the major-league bench.
Not only might this second base/utility player(s) arrangement change by the opener, but it could very well reshuffle several times during the season, perhaps paving the way for Brito or, late this summer, top prospect Travis Bazzana.
Outfielders (4): Steven Kwan, Lane Thomas, Will Brennan, Jhonkensy Noel
Others in camp: Chase DeLauter, Petey Halpin, Johnathan Rodriguez, George Valera
Since all of the second-base candidates can shift to the outfield, this is rather simple. Kwan and Thomas will occupy left and center, respectively. Brennan and Noel figure to split right-field duties, unless someone can crash the party. DeLauter’s delayed start to spring action makes it unlikely he breaks camp with the club. If he stays healthy, DeLauter is primed for a big-league audition, but the first word of this sentence is awfully important.
If the club needs a right-handed stick at some point, Rodriguez is ready for a look. If the club needs a left-handed stick at some point, Valera could be an option.
Starting pitchers (5): Tanner Bibee, Luis Ortiz, Gavin Williams, Ben Lively, Triston McKenzie
Others in camp: Kolby Allard, Logan Allen, Shane Bieber, Joey Cantillo, Slade Cecconi, Will Dion, Daniel Espino, John Means, Doug Nikhazy, Vince Velasquez, Ryan Webb
Don’t just look at spring training statistics. Don’t just look at spring training statistics. Don’t just look at spr—
OK, the starting pitching performances have been, uh, a bit shaky thus far. But it’s always more about those spring clichés — how the ball is coming out of a pitcher’s hand, whether they’re attacking the zone and repeating their delivery, if they’re putting in the work each and every day — than stats from a handful of innings of work.
The Guardians have a lot of different scenarios to consider. For instance, Lively and McKenzie are out of minor-league options. They won’t be going to Triple-A Columbus; it’s either the rotation, the bullpen or another team for them. Velasquez and Allard, as veteran non-roster invitees, have opt-out clauses and some authority over where they wind up.
McKenzie’s last outing — in which he walked five and recorded only two outs — offered a vivid reminder of his struggles from last season. Would a trip to the bullpen to begin the season help him? That could open a spot for Allen or Cecconi or one of the veterans. There’s still time for the starters to round into form, but the ultimate Opening Day setup could remain a question mark for a few weeks, especially since there’s a bit of unrest in the bullpen.
Relievers (8): Emmanuel Clase, Hunter Gaddis, Tim Herrin, Cade Smith, Paul Sewald, Andrew Walters, Jakob Junis, Kolby Allard
Others in camp: Franco Aleman, Tanner Burns, Nic Enright, Luis Frías, Bradley Hanner, Sam Hentges, Mason Hickman, Zak Kent, Jack Leftwich, Andrew Misiaszek, Parker Mushinski, Erik Sabrowski, Trevor Stephan
Several things can be true at once about this group. One, Cleveland’s bullpen has a shot to repeat as the most proficient bullpen in the league. Two, there’s undoubtedly some regression on the horizon; can all of Clase, Smith, Gaddis and Herrin post sub-2.00 ERAs again? Seems impossible. Three, there’s plenty of depth to compensate for some of that regression, even after the team traded Nick Sandlin and Eli Morgan and cut ties with Pedro Avila. Four, that depth is looking a bit shaky at the moment, thanks to a rash of injuries.
They’re taking extra care with Sabrowski, who completed his first full season in 2024 following a pair of Tommy John surgeries. Hentges is out for the year following shoulder surgery. Aleman will miss the start of the season because of surgery to repair a hernia. Enright is dealing with a lat strain. Stephan is working his way back from elbow surgery.
So, we’ll go with Allard, presuming the Guardians want a second left-hander on the staff in addition to Herrin. But they also could spin the reliever roulette wheel and go with Mushinski.