Guardians located in predictable spot in FanSided’s first power rankings of 2026
By Henry Palattella
16 hours ago
Last year, the Cleveland Guardians spent most of the season hanging around the middle of the pack. Sure, they went on a couple runs and had one huge swoon in July, but they spent most of the season hovering around .500 — which led to them hanging around the middle of most publication’s power rankings.
But then that changed at the end of the season when the Guardians finished the season with a 20-7 September that pushed them to their second-straight American League Central title.
But all of the momentum they gained as a part of that wild run has disappeared over the past three months thanks to a quiet offseason that’s been limited to signing some relievers to cheap deals.
On Friday, we got another example of exactly how some in the baseball world view the Guardians’ underwhelming offseason thanks to Chris Landers’ newest MLB power rankings for FanSided, where he had the Guardians listed at No. 15 — smack dab in the middle.
“Can someone please get Jose Ramirez some help? Barring a surprise sell-off of someone like Steven Kwan, the Guardians should return most of last year's division winners, and they always seem to churn out pitching and find a way to punch above their weight. But it took a miracle to capture the AL Central, and while the farm system is exciting (and growth from guys like Kyle Manzardo, Brayan Rocchio and Chase DeLauter should help), there's still just not enough offense here,” Landers wrote.
While we’re a bit more bullish on the Guardians’ young bats than Landers, he’s right in that Cleveland’s lack of offensive additions has been inexcusable, especially given how many clear holes they have.
The Guardians are going to be a middle-of-the-pack team until they add to their offense
Along with having two black holes in center field and right field, the Guardians are also going to enter 2026 with a bit of an underwhelming middle infield picture that consists of Gabriel Arias and Brayan Rocchio, neither of whom set the world on fire last season.
But even with that, it’s hard to imagine a world where the Guardians aren’t in the hunt for a postseason spot thanks to the presence of Ramírez and the team’s strong pitching staff.
Gavin Williams and Tanner Bibee headline a deep, dominant rotation, while the addition to those aforementioned bullpen arms adds even more depth to a unit that handled the loss of Emmanuel Clase with aplomb.
Last year the Guardians were able to make the postseason by going on a historic run while taking advantage of a historic collapse by the Tigers.
It’s an unsustainable model of winning, and the front office clearly thinks that the best way to build a winner in 2026 is to build a team based around strong pitching and young outfielders.
Their middle-of-the-pack inclusion on Landers’ list shows just how much work they’ll need to put in to show that’s the right formula.
<
The first MLB Power Rankings of 2026: Who's on top entering the new year?
Which teams have made the most of the offseason so far, and which have work to do to get ready for Opening Day?
By Chris Landers
Jan 1, 2026
15. Cleveland Guardians
Biggest offseason move so far: N/A
José Ramírez
Speaking of which: Can someone please get Jose Ramirez some help? Barring a surprise sell-off of someone like Steven Kwan, the Guardians should return most of last year's division winners, and they always seem to churn out pitching and find a way to punch above their weight. But it took a miracle to capture the AL Central, and while the farm system is exciting (and growth from guys like Kyle Manzardo, Brayan Rocchio and Chase DeLauter should help), there's still just not enough offense here.
14. San Diego Padres
Biggest offseason move so far: Re-signing RHP Michael King
Managing to retain King was a pleasant surprise, giving San Diego a solid top three to go with that lights-out bullpen. I still just don't see the vision here, though: This remains a terribly top-heavy offense, without much beyond Fernando Tatis Jr., Manny Machado and Jackson Merrill. Neither the lineup nor the rotation likely has the depth to make a serious run, and even AJ Preller might struggle to add more talent with the resources he's been given.
13. Houston Astros
Yordan Alvarez
Biggest offseason move so far: Acquiring RHP Mike Burrows from the Pirates in a three-team deal
Speaking of a lack of depth: How exactly is this Astros rotation cobbling together enough innings to survive as currently constituted? Unknowns and injury risks abound behind Hunter Brown, and it doesn't seem like there's a ton of money in the budget to change that in a meaningful way. Which wouldn't hurt so badly if this lineup hadn't started showing its age; unless Jose Altuve, Carlos Correa and Christian Walker all turn back the clock in a major way — and Yordan Alvarez can finally stay on the field — a Wild Card spot might be the ceiling.
12. Detroit Tigers
Biggest offseason move so far: Signing RHP Kenley Jansen
This is assuming that Detroit decides to hold on to Tarik Skubal for at least the 2026 season, which I still think is the most likely outcome given how hard it is to construct a realistic trade. The Tigers have done some shrewd bullpen work so far this winter, but they still don't have enough behind Skubal in the rotation to win multiple playoff series, and they still haven't found a way to meaningfully upgrade a frustratingly inconsistent offense. There's some room for internal growth here, especially with guys like Parker Meadows (please stay healthy), Colt Keith, Jace Jung and Kevin McGonigle. But that's an awfully tough ask, and there's no reason why this team can't afford an Alex Bregman-type bat.
11. New York Mets
Juan Soto
Biggest offseason move so far: Signing RHPs Devin Williams and Luke Weaver
It's no doubt been a frustrating start to the offseason for the Mets and their fans, but I do think the consensus has swung too low on this team both in 2026 and beyond. Williams and Weaver were strong pivots from Edwin Diaz in the bullpen, and Nolan McLean looks ready for Cy Young contention right away. There are too many holes here to consider them a serious World Series contender as currently constituted — they need to keep adding relievers, plus at least one outfielder and another starter as well — but I'd be surprised if they're not at least in the hunt for a Wild Card spot. And there's still plenty of time left for David Stearns to make a splash.
1
0. Baltimore Orioles
Biggest offseason move so far: Signing 1B Pete Alonso
Baltimore's offense felt ticketed for a bounce-back season even before adding Taylor Ward and Pete Alonso. There's a ton of talent here, assuming that Gunnar Henderson, Adley Rutschman, Jordan Westburg and Jackson Holliday all stay healthy and play up to their potentials. But despite several additions, this pitching staff still makes me a bit nervous: How much do you trust Kyle Bradish, Trevor Rogers, Shane Baz and Zach Eflin to all be healthy and effective at the same time? And was Ryan Helsley really the cure to what ailed this bullpen?
9. Atlanta Braves
Biggest offseason move so far: Signing RHP Robert Suarez
Lord help me, I'm willing to get hurt by the Braves again. This lineup is just too good on paper, especially with Drake Baldwin now on board and a full season of Ha-Seong Kim at shortstop. There are question marks in the rotation (health for Spencer Strider, Chris Sale, Reynaldo Lopez and Spencer Schwellenbach, effectiveness for Hurston Waldrep) and depth concerns in the bullpen despite the addition of Robert Suarez. But if this team can finally avoid the injury bug, why can't they rise to the top of non-Dodgers contenders in the NL?
8. Boston Red Sox
Biggest offseason move so far: Acquiring RHP Sonny Gray and 1B/DH Willson Contreras from the Cardinals
Gray and Contreras are both good players who fill positions of need for Boston, and both were acquired at a price that the organization was comfortably able to pay. But neither are true needle-movers at this point in their careers, and it's hard to avoid the feeling that Craig Breslow still has more to do. The infield is perilously thin, and the offense still feels light on power even if Alex Bregman returns. Add one more starter and one more bat, and we'll really be cooking with gas.
7. Seattle Mariners
Cal Raleigh
Biggest offseason move so far: Re-signing 1B Josh Naylor
Seattle has yet to really dive into this offseason, but another big move or two could (and should) be coming sooner or later. The Mariners have among the deepest farm systems in the sport and are reportedly sniffing around infielders like Ketel Marte and Brendan Donovan. Add one more bat to this lineup, and Seattle should finally have the requisite firepower to pair with that star-studded, homegrown rotation. Pitching has never been the problem, and the offense is coming around.
6. Chicago Cubs
Biggest offseason move so far: Signing RHP Phil Maton
Bringing Shota Imanaga back on the qualifying offer is a big help, and Phil Maton and Hunter Harvey are shrewd additions to a bullpen in need of them. But the apparent loss of Kyle Tucker can't be overstated, no matter how badly his year in Chicago ended. This lineup still looks rock solid, but it's missing a true anchor to build everything around, especially if Pete Crow-Armstrong looks more like he did in the second half than the first. It would be shocking if the Cubs didn't swing a trade for or throw some money at a big-name starting pitcher; get that done, and we can start talking pennant.
5. New York Yankees
Aaron Judge
Biggest offseason move so far: Re-signing OF Trent Grisham
Would someone like to inform Brian Cashman that the offseason has begun? New York has every reason to get aggressive as the Aaron Judge/Gerrit Cole era winds down, and yet they've done almost nothing but sit on their hands so far. Judge covers for a multitude of sins, and the base of talent here remains considerable. But the outfield around No. 99 is a huge question mark, as is the rotation given that all of Cole, Carlos Rodon and Clarke Schmidt will start the year on the IL. (And it's not like Max Fried is Mr. Reliable in that department, either.) Whether the Yankees will ever start spending like the Yankees is one of the most pressing questions for the rest of the winter.
4. Philadelphia Phillies
Biggest offseason move so far: Re-signing DH Kyle Schwarber
It feels like the window is slowly closing on this era of the Phillies, but don't write the obituary just yet. There's still lots of talent here, starting in a rotation that features Zack Wheeler, Cristopher Sanchez, Jesus Luzardo and (eventually) Andrew Painter. The likely departure of Ranger Suarez hurts, and the depth isn't what it once was, but that could still be lethal come playoff time. And if Bryce Harper looks a little more like his old self, the heart of this order can still bang — even if it feels one bat short of truly threatening the Dodgers.
3. Milwaukee Brewers
Jackson Chourio
Biggest offseason move so far: Acquiring LHP Angel Zerpa from the Royals
All Milwaukee does is win a bunch of games each regular season, and that should continue in 2025. It remains to be seen what the team is thinking regarding Freddy Peralta, but even if it deals the right-hander, there should be enough pitching in-house among Brandon Woodruff, Jacob Misiorowski, Quinn Priester, Logan Henderson, Chad Patrick and fast risers. The lineup should once again be chock full of athletes who want to make contact and wreak havoc on the bases, just like they did last year. Whether that will be enough come October is a different question. But it's hard to imagine the Brewers taking much of a step back in 2026.
2. Toronto Blue Jays
Biggest offseason move so far: Signing RHP Dylan Cease
The Blue Jays have attacked this offseason the way a team that came two outs away from a World Series title should. The rotation was the biggest question mark, and that's been just about answered after Shane Bieber surprisingly opted in for 2026 and Toronto went out and signed Dylan Cease and Cody Ponce. Of course, this team knows full well how tough it is to actually chase down the Dodgers, and one more big bat feels essential — whether that's a reunion with Bo Bichette or a run at Kyle Tucker. Get that done, and this team sure feels as well-rounded as any outside of L.A.
[ This article came out just before the Okamoto deal. Don't know how this effects the #1 and #2 rankings. Personally, I move the Jays to #1.
1. Los Angeles Dodgers
Edwin Diaz
Biggest offseason move so far: Signing RHP Edwin Diaz
Could it be anyone else? The two-time defending champs boast an embarrassment of riches in the starting rotation, plus the best player on the planet in Shohei Ohtani at the top of a star-studded lineup. And they began this offseason by aggressively attacking their Achilles heel from 2025, throwing big money at star closer Edwin Diaz. L.A. might not be seriously in on more big fish like Tucker, but they have the cash and the farm system to do just about anything they want. Even if they prioritize another versatile bench piece and call it a day, though, they're the kings until someone takes the throne from them.
<