Tigers, Guardians, Royals rule the American League: The week in baseball
Updated: May. 10, 2025, 12:48 p.m.|Published: May. 10, 2025, 12:30 p.m.
By Paul Hoynes, cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio — Last season, three AL Central teams made it to the postseason — the Guardians, Detroit and Kansas City. The baseball elite rolled their eyes, sniffed indignantly and pointed to the doormat White Sox, a member of the AL Central, as the reason why.
Since the White Sox set a modern-day record with 121 losses, they had a point.
Can they use the same reasoning this year with nearly 25% of the season in the books? Perhaps, but not to the extent of last year when a full season could be weighed and dissected.
When Saturday dawned in the AL, Detroit (26-13), the Guardians (23-15) and Kansas City (24-16) owned the top three records in the league. The Yankees (22-16), Houston (19-18), the homeless Athletics (20-19) and Red Sox (20-20) were next.
It’s not like the Tigers, Guardians and Royals have been taking turns trouncing the White Sox every other day to pad their numbers. The Royals are 4-0 and the Tigers and Guardians are 3-0 against Chicago this year. Meanwhile, preseason contenders such as Houston (1-2) and Boston (4-3) have had problems with the White Sox.
The fact is that there’s winning baseball being played in the AL Central. The Tigers, through Friday’s game, have won five straight and eight of their last 10 games. The Guardians have won three straight and eight of their last 10. The Royals have won seven straight and nine of their last 10, while the Twins have won six straight and six of their last 10 games.
The problem from the Guardians’ point of view is that as well as they’ve been playing, the Tigers are playing better. These teams met in the postseason last year with the Guardians winning a tense ALDS in five games. In the 2024 regular season, the Guardians won the season series, 7-6.
Lefty Tarik Skubal has helped the Tigers stay atop the AL Central. AP
The two teams seemed destined to run neck-and-neck this year, and so far, that’s how it has gone. They meet for the first time this season at Comerica Park for a four-game series from May 22-25. It will be a good test.
The Tigers, who have played one more game than the Guardians, own the statistical edge in several categories.
Offensively, the Tigers rank second in the AL in runs (210), batting average (.259), OPS (on-base percentage + slugging percentage), third in walks (139) and fourth in homers (48).
The Guardians rank sixth in runs (163), 10th in batting average (.239), sixth in OPS (.705), sixth in walks (124) and seventh in homers (45).i
From an overall pitching standpoint, the Tigers have the second lowest ERA (2.90) and batting average against (.216) in the league. They rank sixth in strikeouts (331) and 11th in walks (112).
The Guardians rank 10th in ERA (4.19) and 13th in batting average against (.260). They rank third in walks (147) and ninth in strikeouts (314).
The Tigers’ rotation, led by Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal, is 18-10 with the third lowest ERA (3.20) in the league. They rank second in strikeouts (216), ninth in walks (68) and fifth in batting average against (.227).
The Guardians’ rotation, led by Tanner Bibee, is 11-12 with the 14th ranked ERA (4.54) in the league. They rank 11th in strikeouts (169), first in walks (96) and 14th in batting average against (.261).
The Tigers’ bullpen is 8-3 the lowest ERA (2.39) in the league. They rank sixth in saves (11), first in batting average against (.197), 14th in strikeouts (115), 12th in walks (44) and 15th in hits (91).
The Guardians’ bullpen is 12-3 with the ninth ranked ERA (3.72). They are tied for second in saves (13), 13th in batting average against (.258), fifth in strikeouts (145), eighth in walks (51) and third in hits (141).
Javy Baez has added versatility to the Tigers lineup by agreeing to play center field this season.AP
Detroit’s offense has been productive throughout the lineup. Spencer Torkelson, the overall No. 1 pick in 2020, has bounced back from getting optioned to Triple-A last year, and leads the team with 10 homers and 32 RBI.
Veteran Javier Baez, bouncing between the infield and center field, is hitting .308 (33 for 107) with three homers and 19 RBI after playing just 80 games last year because of injuries.
Free agent Gleyber Torres has been solid at second base, hitting .284 (29 for 102) with four homer and 20 RBI. Outfielders Riley Greene and Kerry Carpenter have been productive as well. Greene is hitting .276 (35 for 127) with eight homers and 21 RBI, while Carpenter is hitting .276 (35 for 127) with eight homers and 20 RBI.
The rotation of Skubal (4-2, 2.08), Jack Flaherty (1-4, 3.79), Casey Mize (6-1, 2.53), Reese Olson (4-2, 3.03) and Jackson Jobe (2-0, 4.88) has given manager A.J. Hinch a more traditional approach than the “pitching chaos” plan he used last year to reach the postseason. The work of the rotation has helped keep the bullpen’s workload to only 128 innings. The Guardians’ pen has pitched 142 2/3 innings.
The Guardians, after 38 games last year, were 24-14 with a 1 1/2 game lead in the AL Central. They held off every challenge presented by Detroit, Kansas City and Minnesota to win the division.
This year the roles may be reversed.
<