Why did Guardians trade Josh Naylor? – Terry Pluto
Updated: Dec. 21, 2024, 8:49 p.m.|Published: Dec. 21, 2024, 8:38 p.m.
By Terry Pluto, cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio – At the Guardians' postseason press conference, I asked about Josh Naylor’s weight and physical conditioning.
Team president Chris Antonetti gave a bland non-answer. Manager Stephen Vogt gave Naylor credit for playing through a variety of minor injuries, praising his toughness.
I listened politely, a follow-up question didn’t yield much other than Naylor had a very good season for Cleveland – which he did.
But I sensed a trade was coming, despite Naylor’s 2024 All-Star season. I had been hearing whispers that the Guardians were concerned about Naylor’s weight for quite a while. He’s listed at 5-foot-11 and 250 pounds by Baseball Reference. I was hearing from scouts about Naylor looking as if he was gaining weight during the season – and he was well over 250 pounds.
Not all about the money
For real, this wasn’t a pure salary dump.
Naylor is projected to make $12 million in his final arbitration season. The Guardians signed Santana for $12 million. Both players are on one-year contracts.
So what’s the story?
Naylor made the All-Star team, batting .243 (.776 OPS) with 31 HR and 103 RBI. It was a big year. He did it batting fourth, behind Jose Ramirez. That helped the superstar have a huge season (.279, 39 HR, 118 RBI, .872 OPS). Teams just couldn’t continually walk Ramirez because Naylor had a power bat.
The surface numbers don’t dictate a reason to move off Naylor, who should be motivated to get into better shape as he’ll be a free agent after the 2025 season.
The Guardians traded Naylor to Arizona for pitcher Slade Cecconi, a Competitive Round B pick and Carlos Santana.
Yes, that Carlos Santana … back for a third tour of duty with Cleveland.
Technically, Santana wasn’t part of the deal. He was a free agent and signed with Cleveland. Adding Santana opened the door for Cleveland to make the trade.
After the All-Star break, Naylor batted .240 (.717 OPS) with nine HR and 38 RBI in 62 games. He had 22 HR and 70 RBI in 89 games before the All-Star break.
Was the decline due to Naylor simply cooling off, or was it because of weight impacting his swing – which seemed longer and slower later in the season.
The Guardians aren’t saying anything about his conditioning, but it has to be a factor.
Naylor missed only 10 games in 2024. In 2022-23, he missed a combined 81 games due to injuries.
Then there’s Santana
He will be 39 on April 8.
He played 150 games for the Twins in 2024, batting .238 (.749 OPS) with 23 HR and 71 RBI. He won the first Gold Glove of his career … yes, at the age of 38.
The Guardians love Santana. He’s respected as a leader and is very close to Ramirez. This deal says Cleveland believes his production can be close to Naylor’s in 2025.
The deal also sets up Kyle Manzardo for more playing time. One of their top prospects, Manzardo struggled early in 2024 and was sent back to the minors. When he returned after the All-Star break, the lefty batter had a .270 average (.873 OPS) with five HR in 69 plate appearances.
Then there’s Santana
He will be 39 on April 8.
He played 150 games for the Twins in 2024, batting .238 (.749 OPS) with 23 HR and 71 RBI. He won the first Gold Glove of his career … yes, at the age of 38.
The Guardians love Santana. He’s respected as a leader and is very close to Ramirez. This deal says Cleveland believes his production can be close to Naylor’s in 2025.
The deal also sets up Kyle Manzardo for more playing time. One of their top prospects, Manzardo struggled early in 2024 and was sent back to the minors. When he returned after the All-Star break, the lefty batter had a .270 average (.873 OPS) with five HR in 69 plate appearances.
He can play first and DH.
They also added 25-year-old righthander Cecconi, who was 2-7 with a 6.66 ERA for Arizona. In the minors, he was 4-2 with a 3.06 ERA for Class AAA Reno. He was the No. 14 prospect for the Diamondbacks, according to Baseball America.
The Guardians had no intention of signing Naylor to a long-term deal. They offered the lefty hitter to several teams. Interest was limited, despite his big numbers. His conditioning was a concern.
Of course, Naylor could have a huge season for Arizona, especially if he gets in shape. And age can finally catch up with Santana.
It’s worth noting Naylor originally was a first-round pick by Miami in 2015. He then was traded to San Diego. Then traded to Cleveland. Now, Arizona.
Like with the Andres Gimenez trade, I’m giving the front office the benefit of the doubt because they earned it. That said, I was very worried about Naylor’s future, be it injuries or adding more weight.
<