How Cleveland’s Austin Hedges learned to stop worrying (about hitting) and love his job
Cleveland Guardians' Austin Hedges reacts as he jogs the bases after hitting a two-run home run against the Seattle Mariners during the fourth inning of a spring training baseball game Sunday, Feb. 25, 2024, in Peoria, Ariz. (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
By Tyler Kepner
6h ago
GOODYEAR, Ariz. — Austin Hedges wants to manage someday, and he already knows the main task. Good managers create an environment for players to be their best selves.
“And it’s tough, because most guys are trying to figure out what other guys do — this guy does this, that guy does that,” said Hedges, a catcher for the Cleveland Guardians. “But it’s like: ‘What do you do? Figure out what makes you great. Everyone works hard, but what is your thing?’ And just buy into that and obsess over it every single day.”
Hedges, now entering his 10th season in the majors, is exceptionally good at one thing and historically poor at another. He will always work on his hitting, always believe he can make a breakthrough, always remember that he has hit dozens of home runs at the highest level of his profession.
Yet no player in the last century has come to the plate as often as Hedges with a batting average so low. In 2,213 career plate appearances, Hedges has batted just .189. The only position player with more plate appearances and a lower average, a catcher named Bill Bergen, retired in 1911.
For Hedges, accepting his limitations has helped him accentuate what makes him great.
“But it was hard to get there,” Hedges, 31, conceded. “And the only way I got there was by getting out enough where I’m like, ‘OK, but they’re still throwing me in the lineup. They still want me here. Why? If I can’t help the team offensively, then I’ve got to be able to do something else.’”
Teams keep giving Hedges millions each season to mentor their pitchers, plan their strategy and catch about half their games. He helped Cleveland reach the playoffs in 2020 and 2022, then spent most of last season with Pittsburgh before winning a championship with Texas.
After slipping from 92 wins in 2022 to 76 last season, the Guardians made sure to bring Hedges back. They signed no other major-league free agents for more than $750,000, but found $4 million in their tight budget for Hedges.
“The rapport he builds with pitchers, even when he’s not in the game — just the way he converses with them, the energy he brings, the way he helps in game planning, we missed that a lot last year,” General Manager Mike Chernoff said. “That, in our minds, completely outweighs the offense.”
The Guardians, who outslugged only Oakland last season, added no offensive thump and will rely again on their pitching. Starter Triston McKenzie, who is healthy after missing most of last season with shoulder and elbow trouble, said he was eager to reunite with Hedges.
“He puts two, three, four times, five times the effort than I’ve ever seen catchers put in, in terms of labeling scouting reports, going through each hitter, figuring out a plan of attack and making it customizable to whoever’s on the mound that day,” McKenzie said. “It allows a lot of stress to be taken off our minds.”
Stephen Vogt, the former catcher and new Cleveland manager, said Hedges had some of the best hands in the game and uncommon patience in receiving each pitch. Minimal glove movement helps Hedges frame strikes, and the data supports his reputation.
Last season, Sports Info Solutions credited Hedges with a major-league-best 11 strike zone runs saved, a metric that attempts to measure, in runs, a catcher’s impact on ball-strike calls. Two others tied Hedges (the Mets’ Francisco Alvarez and the Giants’ Patrick Bailey), but both caught at least 1,000 more pitches.
Hedges also scores well in Sports Info Solutions’ defensive runs saved calculations. In the company’s 21 seasons of data, Hedges ranks fifth, behind Yadier Molina, Russell Martin, Buster Posey and Jeff Mathis — all of whom caught hundreds more games.
For Hedges, catching has been a lifelong passion. Bored by the other positions, he was working by age 13 with a catching instructor, Brett Kay, who would later coach him at JSerra Catholic High School in San Juan Capistrano, Calif. Hedges hit well there, but scouts had their doubts.
“I remember when he was going to get drafted, they always questioned the hit tool,” Kay said. “And I’m like, ‘Listen, it’s not the hit tool that’s going to take him to the big leagues, and it’s not the hit tool that’s going to make him stay there for 15 or 20 years. Yes, if he hits, he’ll be a Hall of Famer. That’s how good he is defensively. But his long-lasting power is his defense and his ability to be a great teammate.’”
Hedges, who was drafted in the second round by San Diego in 2011, was the ideal pupil for Kay, who learned the position from two of the masters: Bob Boone, a four-time All-Star and family friend, and Gary Carter, a Hall of Famer who coached Kay in the minors with the Mets.
From them, Kay knew the value of presenting a pitch to the umpire — framing, that is — long before analysts quantified it. He taught Hedges the art of receiving the ball, how to angle his body and manipulate the glove to get borderline pitches called strikes. Hedges responded eagerly, with a perfectionist’s attention to detail.
“I just tried to make everything a strike, and by the time I got to pro ball and the big leagues, I had done it and other guys hadn’t even thought about it,” said Hedges, who reached the majors in 2015. “But then what happens is the league starts figuring out how to do some things, and I went from, like, the top of the league to flirting with the top 10. I was like, ‘What’s happening here?’”
Hedges had hit .163 in 2022, but started all seven of the Guardians’ postseason games. The Pirates, hoping to add moxie to a young clubhouse, signed Hedges for one year and $5 million. He bonded immediately with their catching coach, Jordan Comadena — “He’s a mastermind,” Hedges said — and redefined his technique.
Comadena — yes, his nickname is “Funky” — had helped Jacob Stallings win a Gold Glove for the Pirates in 2021. He said he encouraged Hedges to use his strong hands and forearms to “blast through the pitch,” and emphasized that quickness means deception for a catcher.
“They’re moving the ball, but to the umpire, it doesn’t look like it,” Comadena said. “They don’t see where you catch it, they see where you stop it. If it’s catch-move, the umpires see that and you’re not going to trick them as often as you can when it’s a one-piece move.”
The old way of catching, Hedges said, was to be soft with your hands. Working with Comadena, he said, changed his mindset.
“Most catchers are trying to catch an egg and keep it, not break it,” Hedges said. “I’m trying to crack that egg into a trillion pieces. I’m smashing it. Most guys move from their shoulder to raise the ball. I’m trying to press the ball from my elbow, as fast as I can, to a spot that is clearly a strike.”
Pitch selection beats hitters, pitch presentation sways the umpires, but it’s all in service of the pitcher. To Hedges, that is the essence of his job. He can handle the frustration of hitting for the thrill of making teammates better as a catcher.
“My skill set now is making it about everybody else,” said Hedges, who is deeply offended by the notion of an automated strike zone, which Major League Baseball has used in the minors.
“The thing that bothers me about the idea of a full automatic strike zone is you’re just telling me that I wasted my time for 31 years working on this,” he said. “It would be like taking away bunting because people don’t want to watch it. No, that’s a skill for guys that helps teams win games.
“My skill set dictates counts, and leverage counts win ballgames — 1-2 counts win ballgames, 2-1 counts lose ballgames; that’s the difference of the 1-1 pitch. I’ve got infinity amount of receiving work, thousands upon thousands of balls received. And if they take that away, I would take it really personally because that’s my life. That’s my livelihood.”
Hedges is not ready to switch livelihoods just yet. The industry still values the best version of himself. Managing can wait.
Re: Articles
10366"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain