Is the Cleveland Indians offense ready to represent a contender in 2022? No, no, no
Milwaukee Brewers relief pitcher Josh Hader right, hugs catcher Omar Narvaez as Cleveland Indians' Myles Straw walks off the field after the final out of a baseball game in Cleveland, Saturday, Sept. 11, 2021. Hader combined with starting pitcher Corbin Burnes for a no-hitter. (AP Photo/Phil Long)
By Zack Meisel Sep 11, 2021 51
CLEVELAND — Cleveland is home to the vaunted starting pitching factory, the envy of many teams throughout the league. As fate would have it, the Indians have been involved in four hitless efforts this season.
They have never been the team celebrating in the middle of the diamond, however.
The nightmare continues to repeat. Every time, it’s the opposing pitcher(s) carving up Cleveland’s inept lineup. Every time, it’s Cleveland’s hitters sauntering back to the dugout, bat in hand, head down after a brief peek at the sky to search for answers that remain evasive. Every time, bizarrely, it’s Zach Plesac on the mound for the Indians.
The Indians are the first team in MLB history to be no-hit three times in one season. It would be four if their punchless, seven-inning showing in the second game of a doubleheader in Tampa on July 7 qualified for more than a “notable achievement.”
Two nights after the Indians snapped a 25-inning scoreless streak, two Brewers pitchers limited them to one, harmless Myles Straw walk.
“You deal with it, you get up and play tomorrow,” said acting manager DeMarlo Hale. “The good thing about no-hitters, it’s only one loss.”
And that’s true, even if Cleveland has continually surfaced on the wrong side of the highlights and the social media clips during a record-setting season of no-nos. There are nine and counting across the league.
But it does present a timely reason to dissect the driving forces behind the woeful performances at the plate. No hits, one hit, two hits — in the end, the microscopic tally in the hit column is a footnote to the real issues plaguing Cleveland’s roster.
The Indians have hunted for viable outfielders for years. They haven’t drafted and developed an All-Star outfielder since Manny Ramírez, whom they selected 30 years ago. Straw was a shrewd acquisition at the trade deadline; his speed and defense have already paid dividends. But he’s all alone on an island in the middle of Lake Erie.
Cal Quantrill and Triston McKenzie have taken significant leaps in recent weeks, which equips the club with a stout starting rotation for the 2022 season. But there has been a substantial lack of progress on the position player development side of the equation. Aside from Amed Rosario, who has recaptured his 2019 form — and even that only qualifies as league average, via wRC+ or OPS+, though his tormenting of lefties and his speed suggest he should stick somewhere — long-term solutions haven’t emerged.
Bradley Zimmer, Oscar Mercado, Harold Ramírez and Daniel Johnson have shared playing time and, aside from a couple of Zimmer home run balls that orbited Saturn, the group hasn’t offered much to convince the front office the outfield is in good shape. Johnson was optioned to Triple-A Columbus on Saturday. None of the overall numbers for Owen Miller, Andrés Giménez or Yu Chang screams “2022 second baseman,” either.
The team could wield a playoff-caliber rotation. It boasts an imposing closer who deserves some American League Rookie of the Year consideration. José Ramírez has two more years of team control remaining, and paired with Franmil Reyes, the club has its middle of the order secured.
But Cleveland needs some reinforcements. And if this ownership group plans to deliver on its word that the payroll will increase, it’s long past time, either through free agency or a trade, to solve the outfield calamity that has hampered the team for more than a decade.
Four Cleveland hitters own a wRC+ or OPS+ better than league average: Straw, Reyes, José Ramírez and Bobby Bradley. The bottom four in the lineup each night is a patchwork, hodgepodge mix of underperforming, inexperienced players. This season, Cleveland’s team run creation ranks 24th in the league, ahead of only the Royals, Marlins, Diamondbacks, Rangers, Pirates and Rockies. Those are the dregs of the league, the antithesis to good company.
Cleveland’s team slash line stands at .236/.303/.406, or a full roster of slightly worse Harold Ramírezes. It has received nothing at the plate from its catchers, which the team says it can live with because of the pitch calling, framing, blocking and staff-managing abilities of Roberto Pérez and Austin Hedges. But for that to be permissible, Cleveland needs something, anything, from left field or right field or second base. The Indians could even use more from first base, where Bobby Bradley has been exactly what his minor-league numbers would have suggested: a high strikeout rate, a solid supply of home runs and a low average that requires a healthy walk rate to adequately function.
Perhaps they would benefit from a thorough reevaluation of their approach to hitting instruction. Ty Van Burkleo is the league’s longest-tenured hitting coach, a member of Cleveland’s staff since Terry Francona arrived in town for the 2013 season. Victor Rodriguez has served as Van Burkleo’s co-pilot for four seasons. They added Justin Toole to the big-league staff last year to add emphasis to the data side of the operation. Alex Eckelman anchors the hitting development team and oversees the minor-league operation. Every team is attempting to solve the hitting riddle as pitching development has soared in recent years, thanks to advances in data and technology.
Cleveland’s hitters appeared uncomfortable, overmatched and unable to make necessary adjustments all night Saturday, as Corbin Burnes racked up 14 strikeouts, the most by a pitcher against the Indians since the late José Fernández totaled 14 on Aug. 2, 2013, in Miami.
The Brewers snapped the league’s second-longest no-hitter drought, which dated to Juan Nieves’ gem on April 15, 1987. Cleveland, home of the pitching pipeline, owns the league’s longest spell, with no no-no since Len Barker’s magnum opus on May 15, 1981.
The Indians have gone hitless in four of their 140 games (2.9 percent) this season. Minnesota’s Joe Ryan, in his second career big-league outing, carried a perfect game into the seventh inning at Progressive Field a mere three days ago.
“You hear conversations in the dugout, trying to make adjustments to how he is being successful,” Hale said about Burnes. “And then he’d get one step ahead of you where he uses his breaking ball.”
Cleveland’s offense has been a step behind for much of the season.
Re: Articles
8236"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain