Meisel’s Musings: Trevor Bauer has a rubber right arm, but was a mysterious injury doing him harm?
By Zack Meisel 10m ago
CLEVELAND — For more than a month, Trevor Bauer has hinted at a physical ailment that has hindered his pitching delivery. He has refused to delve into specifics, and Terry Francona cites HIPAA anytime he’s asked to reveal details.
Those wearing tinfoil hats might wonder if Bauer is strategically attempting to fend off the Indians’ potential trade partners because he doesn’t want to leave behind an organization with which he has found comfort. (For the record: I don’t buy into that conspiracy.)
The pain can’t be completely intolerable, though, because Bauer has tossed at least 105 pitches in 15 of his 18 starts, and at least 117 in four of his past five outings. Bob Feller would be proud.
On Wednesday, Bauer matched his career-high with 127 pitches. Pitch No. 127 clocked in at 96.7 mph.
“Finally felt like myself,” he said, “which is nice after two months of feeling like someone else.”
And his manager’s take?
“Everybody’s a little banged up,” Francona said. “I think he just was having trouble staying over the rubber as long as he wanted to. He’s feeling better about that. That’s about as much as I think I’m allowed to say so I don’t get arrested.”
In an attempt to acquire a bit more clarity on a murky situation, I asked Francona if, given Bauer’s condition, he has fought himself on leaving Bauer out to throw so many pitches.
“The fight I have is that I feel a responsibility also for his career,” Francona said. “You know, you’ve got one arm and I fight that because he fights me to stay out there, which I love. I mean, I love that. Curt Schilling used to do it and — I love it. I don’t want pitchers that want to come out of the game. I admire that about him. But I want him to pitch for 15 years. So I worry.”
Bauer owns a 3.55 ERA and a 4.08 FIP. He registered a 2.21 ERA and a 2.44 FIP last season. His hit rate has actually decreased slightly this year, but his walk rate has increased, his home run rate has doubled and he has already plunked a league-high 13 batters.
Whatever the malady was, it has prevented Bauer from properly assessing the development of his changeup, the pitch he crafted over the winter and implemented into his repertoire.
“It’s been inconsistent and not up to the level that I’d hoped it would be,” Bauer said, “but it’s hard to tell exactly why. Like I said, I haven’t felt like myself in two months. So when I can’t move the way I need to move and I can’t repeat my delivery, it’s hard to evaluate why a pitch may not be doing what it’s supposed to. My cutter’s been slow. My slider’s been slow. Spin rates have been down on most pitches — all the off-speed stuff, anyway. That’s all just a matter of I haven’t been able to move the way I need to move. So, it’s just nice to feel like I’m back to being myself for the first time in a couple of months.”
What do I do with my Hand?
Brad Hand finally proved mortal, as his implosion Tuesday night inflated his ERA to 2.36 from 1.05. After the game, I asked Francona if fatigue could have played a role, given it marked Hand’s fifth appearance in six days. Francona pointed to Hand hitting 94 mph on the radar gun and noted that he, Carl Willis and Scott Atchison consult pitchers about their stamina before games. Hand confirmed he would have spoken up had he lacked the energy to pitch.
But then Francona acknowledged on Wednesday morning that, yes, it’s possible that Hand’s workload might have contributed to the lack of finish on some of his off-speed offerings.
“He pitched five out of six (days),” Francona said. “That’s a lot to pitch. Sometimes things just happen, too.”
Before the busy stretch, Hand only pitched once in a span of eight days, as the Indians knocked around Detroit and played a few lopsided affairs in Texas.
Hand’s fastball velocity is down about 1.2 mph from last season, and batters are faring better against the pitch this year than they have in any year since 2015. His slider, however, remains otherworldly. Hand’s strikeout rate (37.5 percent) is a career high and ranks in the league’s 98th percentile.
(David Richard / USA Today)
Quote to note
“Anyone else, I probably would have let it go. But because it was Frankie, I decided to spin move him. Hit the B button on him.” — Jason Kipnis, on avoiding Francisco Lindor’s Gatorade shower after his walk-off homer on Monday
Final Thoughts
1. Carlos Carrasco has occasionally popped his head into the Indians’ clubhouse in recent days, and he even played catch earlier this week. Doctors have encouraged Carrasco to have some activity when he’s feeling up for it. Carrasco has been sidelined since early June when he was diagnosed with an undisclosed blood condition.
“We all feel like it’s really not just good for his arm,” Francona said, “but good for his brain and good for his psyche and everything.”
2. Corey Kluber will have his right arm examined Thursday. If all goes well, he could be granted a green light to start playing catch and sketch out a throwing program.
3. It’s not exactly cause and effect, but since Oscar Mercado joined the Indians’ roster, the club’s offensive production has spiked.
Since May 14: .258/.335/.474, 108 wRC+, 9.7% walk rate, 19.9% strikeout rate, 214 runs in 40 games
Before May 14: .219/.300/.343, 68 wRC+, 9.7% walk rate, 25.3% strikeout rate, 141 runs in 40 games
4. The Maybe-José-Ramírez-Is-Breaking-Free-Of-His-Nearly-Year-Long-Funk-But-Every-Time-We-Say-That-He-Goes-0-For-8 Tracker: Ramírez is 8-for-19 in his past six games, with four walks and three lost helmets.
5. Despite recent blips on the radar from Hand and Nick Wittgren, the Indians remain atop the league leaderboard in bullpen ERA (3.39), ahead of second-ranked Cincinnati (3.47). It helped Cleveland’s cause that Reds closer Raisel Iglesias surrendered four runs in the eighth inning of a 5-1 loss Wednesday.
(Top photo: Jason Miller / Getty Images)
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain