What Corey Kluber’s fractured arm means for the Cleveland Indians
By Zack Meisel May 1, 2019 18
Corey Kluber can’t repair his jumbled mechanics if his right arm is resting motionless in a sling.
The Indians’ pitching staff has shouldered the load for the first five weeks of the season, and that’s with Kluber — who suffered a non-displaced fracture of his right forearm Wednesday night — pitching more like Brett Myers or Derek Lowe or Eddie Harris than like a Cy Young Award contender.
Terry Francona’s lineup card is littered with question marks, none more frustratingly inquiry-fueling, at the moment, than José Ramírez. The bullpen has pieced together, on balance, a fine showing, though the collection of soft-tossers could certainly use an infusion of steady heat at some point.
The rotation, though, was supposed to be the rock, the foundation of the franchise. When the Indians failed to find a match for an offseason trade involving Kluber or Trevor Bauer, they shifted their payroll-minded roster fixations elsewhere and opted to pin their hopes to the five horses in the stable.
It has worked to an extent. The Indians stand at 16-13, despite an American League-worst offense (69 wRC+, .215/.300/.343 slash line).
Bauer contends he “suck(s) right now,” but his numbers over the last two years — and not just the quantity of plus pitches he possesses — speak for themselves. Shane Bieber has bloomed into a viable mid-rotation piece who has vaulted his ceiling from modest living room to Sistine Chapel. Carlos Carrasco has rebounded from a rough start to rattle off three consecutive strong outings.
But the Indians left themselves little margin for error. And they continue to pay the price, pestered once again by the unswattable injury bug.
The 60-day injured list might be the safest place at the moment for Mike Clevinger, who is already playing catch, weeks ahead of schedule. It’s not out of the realm of possibility that he now returns in June, instead of the doomsday projections that followed his initial diagnosis (well, the one handed down after he claimed he wouldn’t miss a start after straining his upper back). Now that Kluber is sidelined for an unknown length of time, it would surprise no one if Clevinger attempted to further expedite his early return. As it stands, he can’t be activated until June 7.
Kluber will undergo additional testing in Cleveland on Thursday, and the Indians figure to have a clearer sense at that time of how long he’ll be on the shelf.
The Indians needed a fifth starter for next week anyway. They’ll now need a fourth starter for some time, too. It’s a safe bet that Jefry Rodriguez will rejoin the roster. Adam Plutko has yet to fully recover from a forearm injury. Where the team turns for the extra body is anyone’s guess. (Before the name escapes your mouth — Danny Salazar is basically Carmen Sandiego at this point.)
Chih-Wei Hu hasn’t pitched convincingly well at Class AAA. Asher Wojciechowski has. Say those names in succession five times fast. Now say a prayer.
Those are the options in Columbus, unless the Indians choose to stretch out Cody Anderson at the major-league level. Perhaps Bauer will finally get his wish of starting every fourth day (over Francona’s dead body, presumably). For anyone dreaming of a Dallas Keuchel signing — and who knows what sort of financial commitment that would require at this point in the season — remember he would need some time to build up his arm to become a major-league pitcher again.
Thing is, the Indians need Kluber. A midseason two-week breather on the injured list — a wink-wink transaction of sorts — can sometimes do wonders for a hurler. A 102 mph line drive off one of the most important of the body’s 206 bones, for someone in the pitching profession, does nothing but harm. (And of course Kluber exhibited zero emotion or facial expression after being struck by the baseball. Way to stick to the bit.)
Kluber has been fighting his mechanics all season. His statistics detail uncharacteristically poor command, which has translated to a career-worst walk rate, a career-worst hit rate and an ERA figure resembling a limping quarterback’s 40-yard dash time at the NFL combine.
When he wants to paint the corner, he leaves the ball over the middle of the plate. When he desperately needs to pound the strike zone, he misses by a few ZIP codes. The Marlins entered Wednesday’s game with a .225 team batting average. They knocked around Kluber for eight hits before the right-hander exited.
The Indians’ climb toward a fourth consecutive AL Central crown just grew more daunting. The Twins have feasted on the Orioles, but all signs point to them remaining a factor in the division race through the summer. Meanwhile, the sturdiest part of the S.S. Francona just sprung another leak.
However long Kluber needs to heal, the Indians won’t miss the 5.80 ERA or the .300 opponent batting average. But they will miss the potential Kluber offered, provided he could unearth the remedy to his mechanical woes.
(Photo: Jasen Vinlove / USA Today)
Re: Articles
6781"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain