The making of the Cleveland Indians’ Rotation of Domination
Zack Meisel 2h ago 4
CINCINNATI — When Mike Clevinger strolls past the bathroom stall in the visitors clubhouse at Great American Ball Park, his brain sketches an outline of his once-reeling body.
His knees dig into the tile floor. His head hovers above the toilet bowl. His hair dangles from the sides of his navy cap.
Clevinger made his major-league debut at this venue two years ago. He wandered around Joe Nuxhall Way before an Indians employee directed him to the entrance. He darted for the wrong bullpen before Mike Napoli ushered him to the proper warmup area. And, less than an hour before first pitch, Clevinger hunched over and spewed every last drop of substance from his body, jeopardizing his attendance at his pregame treatment session.
Clevinger no longer vomits before his starts — well, aside from a brief bout with a stomach bug last month in Detroit. He’s made strides in many other areas since that mid-May evening in 2016, too.
The journey hasn’t been seamless. The Indians were stationed in Cincinnati in August 2014 when they completed their trade for Clevinger, then a scuffling right-hander navigating his way back from Tommy John surgery.
These things take time. None of the Indians’ four core starting pitchers — each acquired in separate trades over a five-year span — traveled a direct path, but each lane has converged at the same intersection. And now the club boasts four of the American League’s top nine hurlers, in terms of fWAR (and four of the top 14, by ERA).
The rotation is the franchise’s foundation, the logic behind the Indians serving as either a trendy preseason pick or an obvious one during Terry Francona’s tenure in Cleveland. It’s the reason the team has weathered storms in the bullpen and the outfield this season, the reason those in the clubhouse and those in the fourth-floor offices at Progressive Field maintain confidence in the club’s chances this October and beyond.
The organization crafted the blueprint nearly a decade ago. It required some shrewd talent swaps, some fortune and plenty of player development. There have been hurdles along the way. Danny Salazar’s right arm hasn’t provided as much mileage as the team would have hoped. Cody Anderson turned heads in 2015 and promptly vanished in the Arizona desert.
But as some names have changed, other pitchers have blossomed. Trevor Bauer’s ascent equipped the Indians with a second Cy Young Award candidate before a comebacker clanged off his right leg over the weekend. Clevinger has followed through on his aspirations of graduating to a workhorse role this year.
“Usually, teams that are really good have somebody at the top of the rotation that can lead them a long way,” Josh Tomlin said. “We, fortunately, have four of those guys right now.”
It takes patience to construct such a stable. For many starting pitchers, the path isn’t linear. It follows detours to the bullpen, the minors or another roster. But when the timing works, it can produce a force that no opposing club wants to encounter.
Corey Kluber: still an ace. (David Maxwell/Getty Images)
July 31, 2010
To Cleveland: Corey Kluber
To San Diego: Ryan Ludwick
To St. Louis: Jake Westbrook, Nick Greenwood
At the start of the season, Bauer and Clevinger made a pact: They would monitor Corey Kluber’s workload and attempt to keep pace. They figured he’d wind up near the 220-inning mark, his average over the past four seasons. (He’s headed straight for that number.) Bauer and Clevinger aren’t far behind, though Bauer’s stress fracture has sidelined him from the workhorse derby.
Executives in the Indians’ front office will admit they didn’t anticipate acquiring a Cy Young Award winner when they shipped Westbrook to St. Louis in 2010. They couldn’t locate his name on any of the Padres’ top prospects lists. They appreciated his gaudy strikeout totals, but also noticed his less alluring hit and walk rates.
The club assigned two scouts to watch Kluber’s outings with Class AA San Antonio before it agreed to the three-team exchange. Even when Kluber joined the Indians, he suffered through some rough patches. He posted a 5.56 ERA for Class AAA Columbus in 2011.
Three years — and endless instruction, dedication, mechanical refinement and boosted confidence — later, Kluber captured his first piece of hardware. Now, he’s a three-time All-Star, the captain of one of the league’s most formidable staffs, and he could crash the field of Cy Young finalists for the fourth time in five years.
When Kluber emerged on the big-league scene in 2013, Justin Masterson and Ubaldo Jimenez anchored the Indians’ rotation. It didn’t take long for him to supplant them as the headlining act.
“The guy at the top, how he goes about his business on a daily basis, it sets the tone for the other starters,” Tomlin said. “I’ve been in there and watched it and been a part of it. When it’s his day to pitch, you’re getting the very best of Corey Kluber, and guys around him gravitate toward that. Every fifth day, he’s ready. He has his routine. He knows how he’s going to feel. He knows how he’s going to go out there and compete and he’s able to make in-game adjustments quickly. Guys see that. They watch that.
“You can obviously go look at it and say, ‘I want to pitch like him.’ Of course, everybody does. But what a lot of people don’t understand is it’s the things he does prior to that start — it’s mirrored every fifth day. Every day, it’s the same thing. He knows how his body is going to feel that fifth day. Guys notice that. They start to get in a better routine, better preparation, and once you do that, you’re set up for success. A bunch of guys follow him. And rightfully so. They should.
“You come from different backgrounds and you try to learn different things, but the one thing that stays constant is you have that horse at the very top that keeps everything going. That’s the truth.”
Dec. 11, 2012
To Cleveland: Trevor Bauer, Matt Albers, Bryan Shaw, Drew Stubbs
To Cincinnati: Shin-Soo Choo, Jason Donald
To Arizona: Didi Gregorius, Tony Sipp, Lars Anderson
Burrito in hand, Bauer was sitting at Chipotle when his agent buzzed his phone. He stepped outside and chatted for a few minutes before he returned to the table.
“What’d he have to say?” one friend inquired.
“Oh, I just got traded,” Bauer replied, nonchalantly.
He preferred to fixate on his meal rather than the life-altering news. So he’d have to report to a foreign spring training complex. Big deal. He’d still be in Arizona. He still had two months of the offseason to enjoy. And he still had a burrito to savor.
Once he joined the Indians that spring, however, Bauer quickly realized how desperately he needed a change of scenery to launch his career in the desired direction.
“My first experience here,” he told The Athletic, “I was like, ‘Wow, I needed to get out of there. It’s a refresher. This is a much better fit.’ ”
For years, Bauer offered glimpses of greatness. He talked a big game. He preached about future awards he would collect, sky-high standards he would exceed. He backed it all up this season, with a 2.22 ERA, a 2.38 FIP and career-best walk, strikeout, hit and home run rates. He pocketed the baseball he tossed to record his 200th strikeout of the season, the first time he has reached the milestone.
It’s the long-awaited result of a mastering of the delivery he revamped in 2013. It’s a byproduct of a self-crafted slider and changeup, a pair of pitches he developed over the winter and has unleashed on hapless hitters all summer. It’s the consequence of enhanced knowledge of how to attack hitters and how to astutely respond to their adjustments.
The guy once saddled with the reputation of being uncoachable and undesirable as a teammate has forged a friendship with Clevinger, exchanged jokes with José Ramírez and, with Carlos Carrasco, created mini baseballs depicting each of the players in the clubhouse. And now, the Indians are reaping the rewards for exhibiting patience.
That’s not to say Bauer, Francona and Mickey Callaway didn’t have their squabbles over the years. But that seems to be in the past. And so, too, is the skepticism surrounding Bauer’s atypical warmup routines and training habits.
“This has been a positive environment, especially this year, now that I’m encouraged to talk to teammates and interact in that way,” Bauer said. “It’s been very fulfilling for me. And, hopefully, I’ve been a positive influence on the rest of the guys in some way. It’s been gratifying watching that.
“It’s cool to see other guys having that type of success. I can sit there and wear Clevinger out for having a better slider than him or throwing harder than him or whatever. But there’s a healthy respect there, because I know on any given day, he’s going to go out and completely dominate. And hopefully he realizes the same thing in return. When there’s that healthy respect, you can help each other and help breed success.
“So, in that way, that the timelines have worked out the way they have has been very nice. I don’t think it would be nearly as good of an environment if I was just the ace of a staff and there was a huge gap. I would enjoy trying to help other guys, but, like — sitting in the dugout, watching (Carrasco) punch out 10 or 11 in Minnesota the day after I punched out three, I was sitting there, seething. Like, ‘I should be doing that.’ So, it’s been helpful for me.”
It took some time, but Carlos Carrasco has developed into a steady rotation force. (Dylan Buell/Getty Images)
July 29, 2009
To Cleveland: Carlos Carrasco, Jason Knapp, Jason Donald, Lou Marson
To Philadelphia: Cliff Lee, Ben Francisco
The Indians dealt Lee to the Phillies nearly a decade ago and, for a few years now, Carrasco has been the lone remaining big-leaguer. But even he toiled on the brink of irrelevance.
Indians front-office members stress that the key to player development is to allow a player’s career to unfold on his time, not the franchise’s time. Carrasco’s tale fits that mantra.
He debuted for the Indians in 2009, but didn’t find his footing as a big-league starter until 2014. He persevered through elbow surgery, a host of demotions to Class AAA and even a stint in the bullpen four years ago, a three-month stretch that salvaged his career. His work in the bullpen convinced Callaway and Kevin Cash he was ready for a return to the rotation, complete with a redefined, more aggressive approach. The two coaches talked Francona into the idea, and Carrasco rewarded their decision by recording a 1.30 ERA over 10 starts to wrap up the 2014 campaign.
Since, he has blossomed into one of the league’s most effective starters. He finished fourth in the Cy Young balloting last year.
Consider Carrasco’s consistency over the past four seasons:
Strikeouts per nine innings:
2015: 10.6
2016: 9.2
2017: 10.2
2018: 10.2
ERA:
2015: 3.63
2016: 3.32
2017: 3.29
2018: 3.50
Opponent batting average:
2015: .226
2016: .238
2017: .233
2018: .243
Carrasco might be the most easygoing member of the Indians’ roster and, a few years ago, Kluber encouraged him to maintain that attitude on his start days. Carrasco said the simple bit of advice has made a significant difference.
Marson, Donald and Knapp quickly disappeared from the Indians’ plans. But Carrasco’s evolution, while delayed, has validated the front office’s choice to deal a Cy Young winner to Philadelphia.
Mike Clevinger might hit that 200-inning goal after all. (Dave Reginek/Getty Images)
Aug. 7, 2014
To Cleveland: Mike Clevinger
To Los Angeles: Vinnie Pestano
Clevinger ranks among the AL leaders in ERA, FIP, WAR and innings. And yet, Bauer can recall a few instances this season in which his pal has expressed frustration or displeasure with how his season has progressed.
“It’s like, ‘Take a step back and look where you’re at, man,’ ” Bauer said. “ ‘I’ve been there. I’ve had the same feelings you have.’ But that speaks to the mindset and competition that’s on this staff.”
When Clevinger gains perspective, he harkens back to the grueling days spent recovering from Tommy John surgery in 2013. When he eventually returned to the mound, it didn’t immediately click. He pondered other career paths in biology and wildlife control.
The Indians rescued him, though, at the recommendation of a scout intrigued by Clevinger’s strikeout rate and slider. He offered plenty of promise, the club thought. He just needed some mechanical tweaks. Mike Chernoff noted that a team never truly knows what it’s receiving when dealing for a prospect, but the Indians identified some encouraging signs with Clevinger. And the cost — the last gasps of Pestano’s big-league career — certainly wasn’t prohibitive.
Clevinger knew his arm was composed of major-league material. He just had to learn the art of pitching.
“There’s a lot of figuring out to do with sequencing and hitters and all that good stuff,” Clevinger said. “It’s just getting comfortable with being out there, being me, being in front of these people, being on camera and knowing you’re on the same level as the guys you grew up watching.”
In an effort to aid his mechanics and avoid mid-inning meltdowns, Clevinger studied ways to improve his posture and body awareness last winter. He practiced breathing techniques to allow him to relax during tense moments on the mound. He vowed to log 200 innings, to mold himself into an indispensable piece of the starting staff.
Mission accomplished.
“It’s fun to see a guy mature right in front of you,” Tomlin said, “a guy that maybe just thought he could go out there and roll out of bed and throw 95 mph and get guys out and understand that it took a little bit of that maturation process and figuring out the in-game adjustments. And he’s watching Kluber, Carrasco and Bauer go out there and compete and he goes off of that. He talks to guys on the bench and tries to figure it out.”
Five years ago, Carrasco was challenging the Indians’ faith. Kluber was just emerging on the major-league scene. Bauer was busy rewriting neuromuscular programming (as he would put it). Even two years ago, Clevinger was an unknown commodity, stuck in the fetal position on the bathroom floor of the visitors clubhouse.
“We were all traded,” Clevinger said. “(Carrasco) got jump-started by getting put in the pen. I had to play the gypsy role until I got comfortable and found my own mechanics. Bauer has been on another planet his whole career and has put it together. There’s been a lot of work done by each one of us and by the Indians’ organization.
“I think the stars aligned for us.”
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain