OF INTEREST
Indians Claim Rob Refsnyder, Designate Kyle Crockett & Dylan Baker
By Steve Adams | November 20, 2017 at 4:06pm CDT
The Indians announced today that they’ve claimed infielder/outfielder
Rob Refsnyder off waivers from the Blue Jays and designated left-hander Kyle Crockett and Dylan Baker for assignment. Cleveland has also selected the contracts of right-hander Julian Merryweather and infielders Willi Castro, Yu Chang and Eric Stamets. That series of moves fills the Indians’ 40-man roster and leaves the Blue Jays’ 40-man roster at a total of 33 players.
The 26-year-old Refsnyder split the 2017 season between the Yankees (who originally drafted him in 2012) and the Blue Jays but struggled to a composite .170/.247/.216 slash line. While Refsnyder has long turned in intriguing offensive stats in the minors, he’s batted just .233/.306/.311 in 320 big league plate appearances. At one point, Yankees fans hoped that Refsnyder could hold down the team’s second base job in the Majors, but he’s now split his time fairly equally between second, first base and left field in the Majors.
Chang (No. 4), Castro (No. 9) and
Merryweather (No. 12) each ranked within the Indians’ top 30 prospects, according to Jim Callis and Jonathan Mayo of MLB.com.
<
Pleskoff Scouting Report | Rob Refsnyder
TEAM: New York Yankees
AGE: 24
POSITION: 2B, 1B, OF
BATS: Right
THROWS: Right
HEIGHT: 6-foot
WEIGHT: 200 pounds
ACQUIRED: The New York Yankees selected Refsnyder in the fifth round of the 2012 First-Year Player Draft out of the University of Arizona in Tucson, Ariz.
STRENGTHS
First and foremost, Refsnyder is known as a good hitter capable of providing a solid batting average. He has spent parts of six seasons in the Yankees minor league system, compiling a fine .291 batting average.
Refsnyder’s best and most productive season at the plate was probably in 2014. In that season, he played for Double-A Trenton in the Eastern League and Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre in the International League. He had 38 doubles, six triples and 14 home runs on his way to a .318-combined batting average. He drove in 63 runs that season.
Refsnyder also drew 55 walks while striking out a career-high 105 times in 577 plate appearances.
It isn’t unreasonable to state that his 2014 season gave his career a huge boost and provided speculation among some that Refsnyder was to become the permanent second baseman for the Yankees.
However, Refsnyder’s development wasn’t quite complete. But in 2016 he was given a promotion to the parent Yankees in July and he played in 16 games, 15 of them on defense. He made 46 plate appearances and hit .302. Defensively, he made only one error in 52 chances.
With a history of not hitting many home runs or stealing many bases in his first five seasons, the Yankees made a move to shore up their long-term plan at second base. In December 2015, the club decided to send Adam Warren and Brendan Ryan (a player that was named after the initial trade was announced) to the Chicago Cubs for second baseman Starlin Castro. Castro has assumed the second base role since, gently leaving Refsnyder behind.
While he isn’t a speedster, Refsnyder has sufficient speed to increase his stolen base total if given the opportunity. His speed might clearly a valuable tool, but he hasn’t taken many chances to steal bases.
Refsnyder’s contact rate increased the last two seasons, leaving his 2014 strikeout total behind. He puts the bat on the ball and can use the entire field with his measured swing. He clearly knows his limitations and doesn’t swing for the fences. His value comes in getting on base with a single a double or a walk, moving along on the bases and scoring runs.
Refsnyder has quick hands and quick reflexes at the plate. He is patient and uses good eye-hand coordination to lengthen an at-bat and make a pitcher work.
One of Refsnyder’s greatest assets is his versatility. He can play almost anywhere on the diamond except catcher or pitcher. That versatility could lead to an eventual role with the Yankees as a super utility player.
WEAKNESSES
Refsnyder is not the polished middle-infielder we see on many clubs today. He doesn’t have the greatest range or first step quickness that may provide him with a full-time infield job. He gets the job done on defense, but he could probably be billed as adequate or average, at best.
In today’s game, an average middle-infielder without home run or huge gap power and only marginal footwork struggles to break into the starting lineup on most clubs. However, there are many teams that could benefit from the versatility Refsnyder offers. The Yankees may eventually be among them.
NARRATIVE
Born Kim Jung-sae in Seoul, South Korea, Refsnyder was adopted by a couple from Southern California when he was five months old. His father Clint was a former college basketball player at Muhlenberg College in Pennsylvania.
He went to Laguna Hills High School in Laguna Hills, California. Always a good hitter, he won high school conference honors. A good athlete, he also played high school basketball and football. He was heavily recruited to play quarterback at several Pacific-10 colleges.
Refsnyder was the starting right fielder on the Arizona Wildcats winning 2012 College World Series team. He was named the College World Series Most Outstanding Player. He was selected by the Yankees in the 2012 Draft and immediately converted from the outfield to second base.
Refsnyder drew attention from scouts while playing both in college at Arizona and in the Cape Cod League. As a junior at Arizona, he hit .352 while leading his team with six home runs.
Refsnyder found himself on the Yankees prospect radar almost instantly. In fact, there was a great deal of buzz surrounding him and many scouts felt the Yankees had found their second baseman of the future. So far, that has not materialized.
While things never really fell into place for Refsnyder at second base, the Yankees began giving him opportunities in the organization to fill-in upon occasion at first base, third base and right field, using him as a super utility player wherever needed.
THE FUTURE FOR REFSNYDER
Refsnyder is beginning to profile as a “jack of all trades” utility player that could always be a phone call away from a major- league job. This season he his assigned back at Triple-A Sacramento/Wilkes-Barre. He’s off to a tough start in his first four games, getting only one hit in 14 plate appearances so far. There will be those who question his ability to sustain a solid batting average against quality pitching.
Perhaps Refsnyder will be a Quad-A player-a guy that comes and goes between the highest level of minor league baseball and major-league baseball.
Refsnyder is not currently on the Yankees 25-man roster. Players such as Pete Kozma and Ronald Torreyes are taking the roles of utility infielders. Aaron Hicks and Aaron Judge virtually platoon as the 4th outfielder. So Refsnyder has to wait patiently for his turn.
CONCLUSIONS
South Korean born and California raised, Rob Refsnyder is a very good athlete with a solid hit tool.
Versatile enough to play second base, third base, first base and the outfield, Refsnyder is seen as marginal or average at best on defense. That factor may figure in the calculation of him as a Quad-A type player.
Refsnyder makes good contact at the plate, but his power has not yet fully developed. He isn’t quite a threat to hit home runs. However, he can spray the ball and hit the gaps for doubles. He runs well and could likely steal some bases if given the chance.
While Refsnyder doesn’t flash any one excellent tool, his hitting is strong enough to project a good batting average and an ability to see lots of pitches, take his share of walks and get on base with some degree of regularity. There are certainly clubs that could use those skills, even if he is relegated to a super utility role.
As a result of his role with the Yankees, perhaps the best opportunity for Refsnyder will occur if he is included in a future trade. That certainly could happen.
Scouting phrase for Refsnyder: A good hitting utility player versatile enough to play several positions
Scouting grade: 45 — A utility player on a major-league team