Fittingly, today is the anniversary of a great day by Rocky Colavito:
(This article is from 5 years ago)
When Rocky rolled: 50 years ago, Colavito's four homers flattened the Orioles in Baltimore
Jamie Turner, Northeast Ohio Media Group
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- It was early June, and the season of '59 wasn't going so well for Rocky Colavito, the Indians' classy, young right-fielder.
Entering a Wednesday night game in Baltimore, the Tribe's cleanup hitter had three hits in his last 28 at-bats, just three home runs in the previous three weeks.
That afternoon, rumors were heating up about a trade to send Colavito to the Boston Red Sox.
"Hey, Rocky, when are you going to snap out of your slump?" Plain Dealer baseball writer Harry Jones asked him during batting practice.
"What slump?" said Colavito, who didn't believe in the word.
"Well, whatever it is," Jones said, "when are you going to get going here?"
"You never know," said the dashing slugger with the jet-black hair and Bronx accent. "Maybe it'll be tonight."
June 10, 1959. Some night.
Plain Dealer fileThe front page of The Plain Dealer's sports section on June 11, 1959 was dominated by The Rock's big night.
Prime-time talent: The next day, Colavito received congratulatory telegrams and an invitation to appear on the "Ed Sullivan Show" that Sunday for $500 while the Indians were in New York to play the Yankees. But the game ran too long for the waiting limo to whisk him away in time. "Good night, Rocky, where ever you are," Sullivan said to close the show.
He's forewarned: Orioles pitcher Milt Pappas, who charted pitches in the home dugout that historic night was scheduled to pitch the next day. After Colavito's feat, Pappas was inundated with post-game questions about how he would face the slugger.
"Well, if he's going to get it, he's going to earn it," Pappas remembers telling the press that night.
Colavito went 1-for-4 the next game, knocking in the winning run with a double in the top of the eighth to win, 2-1.
Repeat performance: It wasn't the only time Colavito slugged four homers in one day. On Aug. 27, 1961, while with the Detroit Tigers, Colavito stroked a home run in the first game of a doubleheader in Washington, then hit three more in his final three plate appearances in the second game to sweep the Senators. For good measure, he hit another the first time up to bat the next day -- making that four straight again.
A rare feat: Only 15 players in major-league history have hit four home runs in one game, according to Baseball Almanac. Only six hit them in four straight at-bats.
A link to history: Ernie Johnson, who served up Colavito's fourth home run that night, has the unusual claim of witnessing three such feats. He was a member of the Milwaukee Braves when teammate Joe Adcock drilled four in 1954, and was an announcer for the Atlanta Braves when Bob Horner smacked four in a Braves loss in 1986.
After 50 years, those who witnessed perhaps the shining moment in Cleveland's hard-luck baseball history since the Eisenhower era still remember much of that special game.
The game was televised in Cleveland, back when baseball belonged to radio -- as if the event were Hollywood scripted.
First-place Baltimore drew 15,883 fans to Memorial Stadium, a cavernous ballpark that measured just 309 feet down the lines but jutted out to 385 in the power alleys and 410 to dead center.
The Indians jumped on the Orioles in the top of the first as left fielder Minnie Minoso stroked a two-out, three-run homer, scoring center fielder
Tito Francona, who had singled, and Colavito, who had walked.
The Tribe clung to a 4-3 lead in the third when Colavito displayed his trademark stretch -- the bat across his shoulders, behind his neck -- before digging in for his second trip to the plate.
With Tribe first baseman Vic Power on first after a walk, Colavito lifted Jerry Walker's pitch over the left-field fence, barely staying fair.
"The one I threw was a high pop up that went down the line," said Walker, now 70 and living in Ada, Okla. "I think he hit a change-up off me."
Today, Colavito remembers the pitch as a fastball, but described it at the time as slider down the middle.
"I knew I hit it good," he said recently by phone, "but I got under it a little."
The blast gave Cleveland a 6-3 lead and sent Walker to the showers.
Colavito got a shower of his own. After catching a ball toward the bleachers in right, a fan tossed a cup of beer in his face. Colavito was livid. He challenged the creep to meet him outside after the game.
Colavito didn't need more incentive at the plate. It didn't matter who Baltimore sent to the mound that night. The next two times up, Colavito pounded reliever Arnie Portocarrero like he owned him.
With one out and the bases empty in the top of the fifth, Colavito lined Portocarerro's pitch over the wall. Indians 7, Orioles 3.
"It was a slider out and away," said Colavito, who lives in southeast Pennsylvania and will be 76 in August, "and how I managed to hit that ball over the left-centerfield fence ... I just went out and got it."
When he returned to the outfield after the second home run, the Baltimore fans booed him.
William S. Nenez/Cleveland NewsRocky Colavito (left, joined by pitcher Gary Bell and catcher Russ Nixon) hit 190 of his 374 career homers with the Indians. His 42 homers in 1959 led the American League, and his 108 runs batted in in 1965 were also a league best.
What's new with The Rock?
Colavito, who is an avid hunter and has rekindled an interest in billiards, said he returns to the Cleveland area a few times a year, most recently for the funeral of his Indians roommate and cherished friend Herb Score. He's a spokesman for Chippewa Landing in Medina County, does an occasional card show and personal appearance, still enjoys watching baseball and considers himself a Cavs fan.
His wife, Carmen, who he met while playing for the minor-league Reading (Pa.) Indians in 1953 and married a year later, is recovering from hip-replacement surgery. They remain close to their three grown children -- sons Steve and Rocky and daughter Marisa.
And about that curse -- the sense among more than a few heartbroken fans that the Indians were doomed to failure after he was traded to the Tigers in 1960. Colavito says he had nothing to do with it, that he didn't put the malocchio -- Italian for "evil eye" -- on the city or its baseball team out of revenge.
"First of all, I love the town of Cleveland," said Colavito, who lived in Lakewood most of his time here and loved to dine at the Theatrical downtown and at a restaurant called Cavoli near Clifton Boulevard and West 117th Street. "I would never do that to the town. I wasn't that way."
Colavito's next turn came an inning later, in the sixth with two out and Francona on second after driving in the Indians' eighth run with a double. The slugger recalled Portocarerro throwing another slider, in the same location on the outside part of the plate.
"And I went out and got it again," he said. "And, again, I knew I hit it hard."
Colavito had hammered his third straight home run for a 10-3 lead. This time, when he trotted out to his position in right, fans greeted him with a standing ovation, including the beer-throwing jerk.
All along, Baltimore's veteran ace reliever Ernie Johnson sat with the team's younger pitchers, boasting about how he would pitch to Colavito to silence the 25-year-old's powerful bat if he were out there.
"I said 'I think we should pitch him tight, it looks like he's reaching out there,'" said Johnson, who lives in Georgia and turns 85 next week.
When the call came for Johnson, who hadn't given up a home run to that point of the season, he figured he'd better pitch to Colavito exactly as he said he would. Colavito's next turn up came in the ninth inning with one out and the bases empty and Johnson on the mound. By then, the Indians' lead had shrunk to 10-8.
Indians pitcher Herb Score, sitting on the edge of the dugout, urged his roommate to swing for the fences.
"I said, 'Are you kidding me? I'm 3 for 28 coming into this game. I have a chance to go 4 for 4.'" He just wanted to swing easy and make solid contact.
The first pitch was high and inside, backing Colavito off the plate.
"So I dug back in," Colavito said. "Nobody was going to scare me."
The next pitch was supposed to be another fastball, up and in.
"And I didn't get it in far enough," Johnson said, "and he hit it over the fence in left."
Four home runs in four consecutive at-bats. Numbers 15, 16, 17 and 18 of the season. Four official at-bats, five runs scored, six runs batted in. His 16 total bases tied a major league record at the time.
Only seven other major leaguers had previously stroked four homers in one game. (Today, 15 have done it.) Only two had hit four straight, including Yankee legend Lou Gehrig, Colavito's boyhood hero in New York until Joe DiMaggio came along.
The usually reserved Colavito jumped on home plate with both feet and tipped his cap to the crowd after number four -- a modest reaction considering what he had just accomplished.
"He took it in stride," said Francona, who hit third in the lineup and went 2-for-5 that night. "Rocky was pretty level-headed."
The feat brought the Memorial Stadium crowd was to its feet. Beer-thrower was nowhere to be found.
Indians pitcher Gary Bell, who evened his record to 5-5 in the Tribe's 11-8 victory that night, had raced from the clubhouse back to the dugout -- on the off chance that history would be made.
"I was standing in my shorts when he hit the last one because I had come running out to watch the last at-bat," said Bell, who had been relieved by Mike Garcia. "I just wanted to see it."
When Colavito arrived at the clubhouse the next day, teammate Jim "Mudcat" Grant, who sang professionally, greeted him with some kind of impromptu "Colavito Cha-Cha," he said.
"Place the name Rocky Colavito next to those of baseball's immortal sluggers," began Jones' game story in the next morning's Plain Dealer, which greeted readers with the banner front-page headline, "Colavito Slams 4 Homers; Tribe Wins."
The best-timed pitch of all was by Kahn's Wieners, which ran an ad in that day's Sports section featuring a picture of Colavito with, "Rocky Colavito shows you how to slug home runs ... and how to get 100% meat energy!"
June 10, 1959, a night of baseball that energized a whole city.