Breaking down the September callup options for the Indians
By Tony Lastoria
August 27, 2013
The Indians players enjoyed a much needed off day on Monday, but on the off day the organization was still hard at work in the offices at Progressive Field. They paid special attention to the action at Double-A Akron and Triple-A Columbus on Monday night as they continue to evaluate September callup options for the stretch run.
With just a few days until the September 1st callup date the Indians will be adding some reinforcements from the minors. They have already been discussing options internally and have been paying special attention to those players over the past two weeks, some getting a visit from various front office personnel to get a firsthand account of them rather than rely on the reports being submitted by the player development staff on site each day.
As a reminder, rosters are expanded in September to allow major league teams to have more than the normal 25-player limit where teams can have up to 40 players on the roster. No team ever has a full roster of 40 players in September, and not every player on the 40-man roster is automatically called up. Teams need to discuss the players that are on the 40-man roster and on optional assignment in the minors and determine if they are ready to help at the big level, and if they are not they simply are not called up. There are also a few players not currently on the 40-man roster that the Indians are considering adding for the stretch run.
The discussions on who exactly the Indians will call up will continue throughout the week in preparation for the first wave of players expected to be immediately called up on Sunday the 1st. You can expect a few relievers to be a part of that initial group and possibly a position player or two. After that, the rest of the callups should arrive after the minor league season ends on Labor Day, which means another wave of players should arrive on Tuesday or Wednesday next week.
Here are the players up for consideration to be called up in September, including those not presently on the 40-man roster, and a detailed explanation why they are or are not being considered for a call to Cleveland:
Pitchers
The Indians have a plethora of relief options to add this September, and they will likely add at least a half dozen arms. Unfortunately, because of the depth of arms they have, some very deserving players are going to get slighted. Here is a look at the pitchers up for consideration:
Josh Tomlin (RHP): This appears to be a slam dunk as the Indians activated him from the 60-day disabled list when they really did not have to and could have just kept him on it the rest of the year so they could use the 40-man spot on another player that can help now. He is scheduled to make a start on Tuesday with Triple-A Columbus, and after that it is anyone’s guess how soon he is up in Cleveland. He could come up on Sunday when rosters expand and take Danny Salazar’s spot in the rotation (innings limit), be called up on Sunday simply as a long relief option, or the Indians may just wait and have Tomlin make one more start with Columbus on Sunday and then call him up as a long relief and spot starting option shortly after that. Either way, he should join the team by this time next week. He’s looked good so far in his rehab as in eight appearances he owns a 2.08 ERA (17.1 IP, 12 H, 0 BB, 12 K), but until he faces major league pitching it remains to be seen just how effective he will be considering he is barely a year away from elbow surgery.
Preston Guilmet (RHP): Guilmet has been very good down the stretch where in seven appearances this month he has thrown 10.0 shutout innings and allowed just 3 hits, 1 walk and has 10 strikeouts. He’s been great all year piling up a 1.73 ERA, 2.0 BB/9, and 10.3 K/9 in 47 appearances at Triple-A Columbus, and he’s been up in Cleveland already a few times and made just two appearances. He won’t excite you with his stuff as he has a low 90s fastball but he has some very good command of all of his pitches and gets great leverage on hitters with the deception and angle his unique over-the-top arm slot creates. He should be a part of the first wave of relievers to help add some length to the pen.
Vinnie Pestano (RHP): My how the mighty have fallen. Pestano has not been himself this year and the Indians finally ran out of patience a few weeks ago when they optioned him to Columbus. His issues this season have been well documented as he has struggled with his velocity and command which have resulted in a large spike in his home run rate (1.6 HR/9) and walk rate (5.1 BB/9). Those are numbers that deep into the season are just not acceptable, especially when you have right-handed relief options aplenty in the minors, so he has been in Columbus for about a month to try and get his delivery right and find the lost life on his fastball. The reports have been mixed as he has looked good some outings but then bad in others (4.22 ERA, 3.4 BB/9, 9.3 K/9), and just from a team standpoint he will probably be recalled but have his opportunities limited the rest of the season.
Matt Langwell (RHP): Langwell is what former manager Eric Wedge would call a grinder. A guy that won’t wow you with his physical tools or his stuff, but a guy that just goes out there and competes, has a lot of toughness, and gets results. He has already been up a few times this season and has had another good year in the minors compiling a 2.31 ERA, 2.9 BB/9 and 7.7 K/9 in 40 appearances at Columbus. He’s a guy that is on the fringe of the 40-man roster, so he will need to continue to get results when given opportunities as there are several right-handed relievers waiting to take his spot. He should come up on Sunday and his performance this September could go a long way at proving whether he stays on the roster this offseason or not.
C.C. Lee (RHP): Lee has made a successful return from elbow surgery this season piling up a 2.67 ERA, 3.0 BB/9, and 11.7 K/9 in 26 appearances in the minors this season, most of them at Columbus. He had a brief callup to Cleveland earlier in the year, and with his unique sidearm slot and good fastball-slider combination and him being one of the Indians top relief prospects, he should get some much needed experience down the stretch in Cleveland as a September callup. However, with all of the depth they have in the pen they may just opt to shut him down and consider it a successful first season back from injury.
Kyle Crockett (LHP): Crockett has rocketed up the system, and he may not be done as the Indians are seriously considering adding him to the roster for the stretch run, something that is almost unheard of for a player drafted just over two months ago. The Indians had him completely skip High-A Carolina a few weeks ago and go right to Double-A Akron, a sure-fire sign that he is in consideration for a major league opportunity right now. The numbers speak for themselves as in 19 appearances he has a 0.40 ERA, 1.6 BB/9 and 11.9 K/9. He just has such exceptional command and is very tough on lefties, something that the Indians could use in Cleveland. He is one of three players the organization is considering adding to the 40-man roster before the end of the season, and he could be a guy that helps fill their left-handed relief need for a long time.
Bryan Price (RHP): Price is having a sensational season, but looks to be on the outside looking in for a September callup simply because of a numbers game. He has been money in August compiling a 0.60 ERA in eight appearances and in 15.0 innings has allowed 7 hits, 1 walk and has 16 strikeouts. For the season he owns a 2.13 ERA, 1.9 BB/9 and 10.9 K/9, which are outstanding numbers for a reliever. He has pedigree as a former high level prospect, but he fell in priority over the prior two seasons due to injuries and inconsistency. He’s reestablished some of his value, and his low-to-mid 90s fastball and plus slider have been true weapons for him this season. But, again, with so many relievers ahead of him on the totem pole and limited space on the 40-man roster, his time for a major league opportunity will probably not come this season.
Blake Wood (RHP): Wood has pitched very well in the minors in his return from elbow surgery as he has a 2.49 ERA and 11.4 K/9 in 28 relief appearances this season, but the walk rate (6.0 BB/9) is concerning and probably will be something that ultimately keeps him from being a September callup. With so many options at their disposal it is hard to see the Indians calling up more than six or seven pitchers and not just callup guys to call them up, which is why I believe that Wood won’t be recalled.
T.J. House (LHP): House has been great in August (2-0, 2.49 ERA, 4:22 BB/K) and has really had a solid season (8-11, 4.10 ERA, 26 GS). He continues to improve his strike throwing ability and he gets a good amount of swing and miss from the left side. He is a guy that the Indians could call up as a long relief option or an additional lefty in the pen the rest of the way; however, the addition of Tomlin might keep him from long man consideration and the Indians may go in a different direction for additional lefty relief help. Even still, he’s proven his value and if he is not called up he has established himself as a major league pitching option for next year.
Nick Hagadone (LHP): Hagadone has kind of been forgotten after his earlier struggles in Cleveland (5.33 ERA, 5.7 BB/9, 8.2 K/9) but he has put together a solid season in Columbus where in 24 appearances he is 2-2 with a 2.48 ERA and has a 5.3 BB/9 and 13.7 K/9. There is no denying his power stuff and his ability to get swing and miss, but command continues to plague him. Like with Wood, the high walk rate may be what prevents him from being called up, not to mention it seems the organization has lost some faith in him.
Austin Adams (RHP), Clay Rapada (LHP), Trevor Bauer (RHP) and Matt Packer (LHP): Adams has returned well from shoulder surgery as his velocity has returned to the upper 90s and his curveball looks great, but there are just too many right-handed relievers in front of him – which is why he has stayed in Akron so long. Rapada has pitched very well, but with the Indians so desperate for left-handed pitching and not yet giving him an opportunity it is a clear indication they do not consider him a major league option and that the Yankees let him go for a reason. At the moment the Indians do not have a need for a starter, and if they do then Tomlin or Carlos Carrasco would probably fill that role, so it is unlikely that Bauer is recalled. Packer has also rebounded well from injury and had a nice season, but again, there are other options above him at this point. He’s definitely added himself to the major league mix next season.
Hitters
David Cooper (1B): The Indians picked up Cooper about two weeks ago and reports said that if he is not added to the 40-man roster by the end of August he can elect to become a free agent. Given that we are just four days away from that deadline, it appears that he will be added to the roster by Sunday. The Indians picked him up because of his bat but he was available because he is coming off serious back surgery. It remains to be seen if he can hold up, but he is hitting .371 with a .878 OPS in nine games. Now, it should be noted a lot of that came in rookie ball action and he has also not shown much power which may be him compromising for his repaired back. That is what the Indians need to see in their evaluation of him before making a decision on whether to roster him, but considering his low cost, the upside if he is healthy, and such little downside if he is not, I have to believe the Indians will roster him and have him on the major league roster in September – provided he checks out health-wise.
Jesus Aguilar (1B): Aguilar has had another good season and he just reached 100 RBIs on the season on Sunday, which is a fantastic feat in the minors. But RBIs in the minors don’t mean much as far as major league ability goes nor do they offer any help in projecting future success. It should be noted that even with the high RBI total, he’s actually had a worse season this year hitting .272 (.280 in 2012), .349 on-base percentage (.372 in 2012), .425 slugging percentage (.461 in 2012) and .774 OPS (.833 in 2012). The Indians like his right-handed power and production and are considering him for a roster spot this September, but that’s a long shot as he is probably not ready and may still be a year away.
Jose Ramirez (INF) and Juan Diaz (INF): The Indians want to add another utility infielder to the roster in September, but the one on the 40-man roster (Diaz) is just not very useful as he offers very little with the bat, has no speed, and is inexperienced at any other position but shortstop. He is hitting just .243 with 8 HR, 44 RBI, .666 OPS and has a poor 43-126 walk to strikeout ratio this season,
which is why the Indians are seriously considering calling up Ramirez as their utility option. That’s the role he will probably fill in the future and maybe as soon as the start of next season, so they may want to get an extended look at him now. He is a plus defender and could even just be a late inning baserunning option because of his excellent speed and smarts on the bases. He has tons of experience in winter ball so the lack of Triple-A experience is not a problem, and he is hitting .277 with 3 HR, 37 RBI, .686 OPS and outstanding 38-40 walk to strikeout rate. That speed, defense, versatility and ability to be a tough out on pitchers is what has him in the mix, and if he is called upon he very well may end up taking Diaz’s spot on the 40-man roster.
Tim Fedroff (OF), Jeremy Hermida (OF) and Matt LaPorta (1B/OF): Fedroff has had a poor year at the plate (.652 OPS). His offensive the last two seasons (.793 OPS in 2011 and .879 OPS in 2012) is what got him rostered and without it he just is not valuable on a roster because is not fast enough or good enough defensively to be a late game replacement as a specialist. If the Indians want to add a guy from the left side with some power, good approach and major league experience, it might be Hermida. He is hitting just .249 but thanks to 87 walks he has a very good .371 on-base percentage to go along with 17 homers and 65 RBI. There is an outside chance that if they do so that he could take Fedroff’s spot on the 40-man roster. LaPorta is hitting .246 with 8 HR, 23 RBI and .793 OPS in 38 games with Columbus, but as much as fans may want to give one last look at him, it appears that when Columbus’ season ends on Monday that the Indians will not call him up and he will quietly leave the organization this offseason as a minor league free agent.
Follow Tony and the Indians Prospect Insider on Twitter @TonyIBI. Also, his new book the 2013 Cleveland Indians Baseball Insider which profiles the Indians' Top 100 Prospects and more is available for sale.
He has tons of experience in winter ball so the lack of Triple-A experience is not a problem,
[ Tony took the words right out of my mouth
]