Indians report: Russ Canzler looks like a future replacement for Travis Hafner
By Sheldon Ocker
Beacon Journal sports writer
Updated: March 16, 2012 - 08:34 AM
GOODYEAR, Ariz.: Nobody will know until he does it in the big leagues, but it sure looks like Russ Canzler can hit.
When the Indians began spring training, Canzler was a guy with no chance to make the team out of camp but who might get a shot in the future, maybe if the Tribe lets Travis Hafner walk next year and needs a designated hitter.
You look at Canzler attack a pitcher, listen to the sharp crack of the bat, shake your head and think, “Unfortunately, there’s always a catch.” In this case, the catch is Canzler’s failure in the past to show he can defend with aplomb.
He batted .314 with 18 home runs and 83 RBI in 474 at-bats at Triple-A Durham last year, compiling a .401 on-base percentage, a .530 slugging average and .930 on-base plus slugging. It was his first season in Triple-A, so there probably was a period of adjustment.
Asked Thursday if Canzler is major-league ready as a hitter, Indians manager Manny Acta hedged, because Canzler has had only three big-league at-bats, with the Tampa Bay Rays.
However, Acta said: “He’s got a pretty good approach at the plate. He’s strong, but he doesn’t allow himself to get pull happy. If he goes down to Triple-A, he’ll probably crush those pitchers, like he did last year.”
On the other side of the ball, Canzler played 40 games at third and committed 13 errors. He played much the same way the previous season, making 17 errors in 56 Double-A games at third. In other words, forget third as an option.
Canzler, who will turn 26 on April 11, played 17 games at first for Durham and was charged with four errors. He also played 33 games in left without committing an error.
Early in camp, Acta said that Canzler would concentrate on playing first in exhibition games. Canzler made two errors the first week, but that probably is only a secondary reason why he will get more reps in left going forward.
“We have a first baseman [Casey Kotchman],” Acta said Thursday. “And to be honest, nobody has stood out [in left]. You’ll probably see Matt [LaPorta] out there, too.”
That is not surprising. The candidates, except for Shelley Duncan and Aaron Cunningham, are nonroster players signed to minor-league contracts. Like Canzler, Duncan is similarly challenged in the field, but Acta knows he can hit and hit with power.
Of the others, Ryan Spilborghs and Felix Pie have had spotty success in the majors, but neither has taken the current opportunity and run with it. Nor has Cunningham.
However, Spilborghs singled twice and drove in two runs against the Chicago White Sox on Thursday. Duncan leads the team with three homers (one Thursday) and 10 RBI. He will make the team whether or not he starts in left.
Earlier in camp, Canzler made an athletic running catch of a drive to the track, about which Acta properly said, “I’m not going to make a decision on one play.”
Canzler was an infielder initially but became an outfielder in 2010, when he was in the Chicago Cubs farm system.
“I played a lot of first base, but a couple of years ago in Double-A, they put me in the outfield,” he said. “I had played the infield my whole life, so it kind of felt like I was being downgraded.”
Canzler played left Thursday and whacked three singles to lift his average to .435 in 23 at-bats. Even if he makes the plays in the outfield, he knows that his future depends on his ability to swing a bat.
“It definitely took me a few years,” Canzler said of the learning process. “I had a couple of rough years in the minors.”
But in 2010, Canzler had a chance meeting with hall of fame slugger Harmon Killebrew before a Double-A game.
“He was sitting in our dugout and was going to throw out the first pitch,” Canzler recalled. “I introduced myself and asked him a few questions. He asked about my family. Then I asked him about his approach at the plate. I was expecting some kind of hall of fame formula, but he simplified everything — get a good pitch and hit it. I was kind of taken aback by that answer.
“My thing was trying to outguess the pitcher. I started applying what he said. After that, I began putting up quality at-bats. If you make a hard out, you should go back to the dugout knowing you put up a good at-bat.”
Killebrew made an impression on Canzler beyond advising him on hitting.
“It was one of the most sincere conversations I ever had,” he said. “He was a great guy. I don’t know that half the guys on the team knew who he was, but that was a great moment in my career.”
Canzler probably doesn’t know if he has a real chance to win the everyday job in left, but he seems to be officially part of the competition as of Thursday.
“I need to make the outs I should make,” he said, “then let my bat do the talking.”
Sheldon Ocker can be reached at
socker@thebeaconjournal.com. Read the Indians blog at
http://www.ohio.com/tribematters. Follow him on Twitter at
http://www.twitter.com/SheldonOckerABJ and on Facebook at
http://www.facebook.com/sports.abj.